多恩布什宏观经济学第十版课后习题答案03-09

申明敬告: 本站不保证该用户上传的文档完整性,不预览、不比对内容而直接下载产生的反悔问题本站不予受理。

文档介绍

多恩布什宏观经济学第十版课后习题答案03-09

CHAPTER3SolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbookConceptualProblems:1.Theproductionfunctionprovidesaquantitativelinkbetweeninputsandoutput.Forexample,theCobb-Douglasproductionfunctionmentionedinthetextisoftheform:Y=F(N,K)=AN1-qKq,whereYrepresentsthelevelofoutput.(1-q)andqareweightsequaltothesharesoflabor(N)andcapital(K)inproduction,whileAisoftenusedasameasurefortheleveloftechnology.Itcanbeeasilyshownthatlaborandcapitaleachcontributetoeconomicgrowthbyanamountthatisequaltotheirindividualgrowthratesmultipliedbytheirrespectiveshareinincome.2.TheSolowmodelpredictsconvergence,thatis,countrieswiththesameproductionfunction,savingsrate,andpopulationgrowthwilleventuallyreachthesamelevelofincomepercapita.Inotherwords,apoorcountrymayeventuallycatchuptoaricheronebysavingatthesamerateandmakingtechnologicalinnovations.However,ifthesecountrieshavedifferentsavingsrates,theywillreachdifferentlevelsofincomepercapita,eventhoughtheirlong-termgrowthrateswillbethesame.3.Aproductionfunctionthatomitsthestockofnaturalresourcescannotadequatelypredicttheimpactofasignificantchangeintheexistingstockofnaturalresourcesontheeconomicperformanceofacountry.Forexample,thediscoveryofnewoilreservesoranentirelynewresourcewouldhaveasignificanteffectonthelevelofoutputthatcouldnotbepredictedbysuchaproductionfunction.4.InterpretingtheSolowresidualpurelyastechnologicalprogresswouldignore,forexample,theimpactthathumancapitalhasonthelevelofoutput.Inotherwords,thisresidualnotonlycapturestheeffectoftechnologicalprogressbutalsotheeffectofchangesinhumancapital(H)onthegrowthrateofoutput.Toeliminatethisproblemwecanexplicitlyincludehumancapitalintheproductionfunction,suchthatY=F(K,N,H)=ANaKbHcwitha+b+c=1.ThenthegrowthrateofoutputcanbecalculatedasDY/Y=DA/A+a(DN/N)+b(DK/K)+c(DH/H).5.Thesavingsfunctionsy=sf(k)assumesthataconstantfractionofoutputissaved.Theinvestmentrequirement,thatis,the(n+d)k-line,representstheamountofinvestmentneededtomaintainaconstantcapital-laborratio(k).Asteady-stateequilibriumisreachedwhensavingisequaltotheinvestmentrequirement,thatis,whensy=(n+d)k.Atthispointthecapital-laborratiok=K/Nisnotchanging,socapital(K),labor(N),andoutput(Y)allmustbegrowingatthesamerate,thatis,therateofpopulationgrowthn=(DN/N).6.Inthelongrun,therateofpopulationgrowthn=(DN/N)determinesthegrowthrateofthesteady-stateoutputpercapita.Intheshortrun,however,thesavingsrate,technologicalprogress,andtherateofdepreciationcanallaffectthegrowthrate.7.LaborproductivityisdefinedasY/N,thatis,theratioofoutput(Y)tolaborinput(N).Asurgeinlaborproductivitythereforeoccursifoutputgrowsatafasterratethanlaborinput.IntheU.S.wehaveexperiencedsuchasurgeinlaborproductivitysincethemid-1990sduetotheenormousgrowthinGDP.Thissurgecanbeexplainedfromtheintroductionofnewtechnologiesandmoreefficientuseofexistingtechnologies.Manyclaimthattheincreasedinvestmentinanduseofcomputer12ntechnologyhasstimulatedeconomicgrowth.Furthermore,increasedglobalcompetitionhasforcedmanyfirmstocutcostsbyreorganizingproductionandeliminatingsomejobs.Thus,withlargeincreasesinoutputandaslowerrateofjobcreationweshouldexpectlaborproductivitytoincrease.(Oneshouldalsonotethatahigher-skilledlaborforcealsocancontributetoanincreaseinlaborproductivity,sincethesamenumberofworkerscanproducemoreoutputifworkersaremorehighlyskilled.)TechnicalProblems:1.a.AccordingtoEquation(2),thegrowthofoutputisequaltothegrowthinlabortimesthelaborshareplusthegrowthofcapitaltimesthecapitalshareplustherateoftechnicalprogress,thatis,DY/Y=(1-q)(DN/N)+q(DK/K)+DA/A,where1-qistheshareoflabor(N)andqistheshareofcapital(K).Thusifweassumethattherateoftechnologicalprogress(DA/A)iszero,thenoutputgrowsatanannualrateof3.6percent,sinceDY/Y=(0.6)(2%)+(0.4)(6%)+0%=1.2%+2.4%=+3.6%,1.b.Theso-called"Ruleof70"suggeststhatthelengthoftimeittakesforoutputtodoublecanbecalculatedbydividing70bythegrowthrateofoutput.Since70/3.6=19.44,itwilltakejustunder20yearsforoutputtodoubleatanannualgrowthrateof3.6%,1.c.NowthatDA/A=2%,wecancalculateeconomicgrowthasDY/Y=(0.6)(2%)+(0.4)(6%)+2%=1.2%+2.4%+2%=+5.6%.Thusitwilltake70/5.6=12.5yearsforoutputtodoubleatthisnewgrowthrateof5.6%.2.a.AccordingtoEquation(2),thegrowthofoutputisequaltothegrowthinlabortimesthelaborshareplusthegrowthofcapitaltimesthecapitalshareplusthegrowthrateoftotalfactorproductivity(TFP),thatis,DY/Y=(1-q)(DN/N)+q(DK/K)+DA/A,where1-qistheshareoflabor(N)andqistheshareofcapital(K).Inthisexampleq=0.3;therefore,ifoutputgrowsat3%andlaborandcapitalgrowat1%each,thenwecancalculatethechangeinTFPinthefollowingway3%=(0.3)(1%)+(0.7)(1%)+DA/A==>DA/A=3%-1%=2%,thatis,thegrowthrateoftotalfactorproductivityis2%.2.b.Ifbothlaborandthecapitalstockarefixedandoutputgrowsat3%,thenallthisgrowthhastobecontributedtothegrowthinfactorproductivity,thatis,DA/A=3%.3.a.IfthecapitalstockgrowsbyDK/K=10%,theeffectonoutputwouldbeanadditionalgrowthrateofDY/Y=(.3)(10%)=3%.3.b.IflaborgrowsbyDN/N=10%,theeffectonoutputwouldbeanadditionalgrowthrateofDY/Y=(.7)(10%)=7%.3.c.IfoutputgrowsatDY/Y=7%duetoanincreaseinlaborbyDN/N=10%,andthisincreaseinlaborisentirelyduetopopulationgrowth,thenpercapitaincomewoulddecreaseandpeople’swelfarewoulddecrease,sinceDy/y=DY/Y-DN/N=7%-10%=-3%.3.d.Ifthisincreaseinlaborisduetoaninfluxofwomenintothelaborforce,theoverallpopulationdoesnotincreaseandincomepercapitawouldincreasebyDy/y=7%.Thereforepeople'swelfarewouldincrease.12n4.Figure3-4showsoutputperheadasafunctionofthecapital-laborratio,thatis,y=f(k).Thesavingsfunctionissy=sf(k),anditintersectsthestraight(n+d)k-line,representingtheinvestmentrequirement.Atthisintersection,theeconomyisinasteady-stateequilibrium.Nowletusassumethattheeconomyisinasteady-stateequilibriumbeforetheearthquakehits,thatis,thesteady-statecapital-laborratioiscurrentlyk*.Assumefurther,forsimplicity,thattheearthquakedoesnotaffectpeople'ssavingsbehavior.Iftheearthquakedestroysonequarterofthecapitalstockbutlessthanonequarterofthelaborforce,thenthecapital-laborratiofallsfromk*tok1andper-capitaoutputfallsfromy*toy1.Nowsavingisgreaterthantheinvestmentrequirement,thatis,sy1>(d+n)k1,andthecapitalstockandthelevelofoutputpercapitawillgrowuntilthesteadystateatk*isreachedagain.However,iftheearthquakedestroysonequarterofthecapitalstockbutmorethanonequarterofthelaborforce,thenthecapital-laborratioincreasesfromk*tok2.Savingnowwillbelessthantheinvestmentrequirementandthusthecapital-laborratioandthelevelofoutputpercapitawillfalluntilthesteadystateatk*isreachedagain.Ifexactlyonequarterofboththecapitalstockandthelaborstockaredestroyed,thenthesteadystateismaintained,thatis,thecapital-laborratioandtheoutputpercapitadonotchange.Iftheseverityoftheearthquakehasaneffectonpeoples’savingsbehavior,thenthesavingsfunctionsy=sf(k)willmoveeitherupordown,dependingonwhetherthesavingsrate(s)increases(ifpeoplesavemore,somorecanbeinvestedinanefforttorebuild)ordecreases(ifpeoplesaveless,sincetheydecidethatlifeistooshortnottoliveitup).yy=f(k)y2y*(n+d)ky1sy0k1k*k2k5.a.Anincreaseinthepopulationgrowthrate(n)affectstheinvestmentrequirement,andthe(n+d)k-linegetssteeper.Asthepopulationgrows,moresavingmustbeusedtoequipnewworkerswiththesameamountofcapitalthattheexistingworkersalreadyhave.Thereforeoutputpercapita(y)willdecreaseaswillthenewoptimalcapital-laborratio,whichisdeterminedbytheintersectionofthesy-curveandthe(n1+d)k-line.Sinceper-capitaoutputwillfall,wewillhaveanegativegrowthrateintheshortrun.However,thesteady-stategrowthrateofoutputwillincreaseinthelongrun,sinceitwillbedeterminedbythenewandhigherrateofpopulationgrowth.12ny(n1+d)ky=f(k)yo(no+d)ky1sy120k1kok5.b.Startingfromaninitialsteady-stateequilibriumatalevelofper-capitaoutputy*,theincreaseinthepopulationgrowthrate(n)willcausethecapital-laborratiotodeclinefromk*tok1.Outputpercapitawillalsodecline,aprocessthatwillcontinueatadiminishingrateuntilanewsteady-statelevelisreachedaty1.Thegrowthrateofoutputwillgraduallyadjusttothenewandhigherleveln1.yy*y1tot1tkk*k1tot1t6.a.AssumetheproductionfunctionisoftheformY=F(K,N,Z)=AKaNbZc==>DY/Y=DA/A+a(DK/K)+b(DN/N)+c(DZ/Z),witha+b+c=1.Nowassumethatthereisnotechnologicalprogress,thatis,DA/A=0,andthatcapitalandlaborgrowatthesamerate,thatis,DK/K=DN/N=n.Ifwealsoassumethatallnaturalresourcesavailablearefixed,suchthatDZ/Z=0,thentherateofoutputgrowthwillbe12nDY/Y=an+bn=(a+b)n.Inotherwords,outputwillgrowataratelessthannsincea+b<1.Thereforeoutputperworkerwillfall.6.b.Ifthereistechnologicalprogress,thatis,DA/A>0,thenoutputwillgrowfasterthanbefore,namelyDY/Y=DA/A+(a+b)n.IfDA/A>c,thenoutputwillgrowataratelargerthann,inwhichcaseoutputperworkerwillincrease.6.c.Ifthesupplyofnaturalresourcesisfixed,thenoutputcanonlygrowataratethatissmallerthantherateofpopulationgrowthandweshouldexpectlimitstogrowthaswerunoutofnaturalresources.However,iftherateoftechnologicalprogressissufficientlylarge,thenoutputcangrowataratefasterthanpopulation,evenifwehaveafixedsupplyofnaturalresources.7.a.IftheproductionfunctionisoftheformY=K1/2(AN)1/2,andAisnormalizedto1,thenwehaveY=K1/2N1/2.Inthiscasecapital'sandlabor'ssharesofincomeareboth50%.7.b.ThisisaCobb-Douglasproductionfunction.7.c.Asteady-stateequilibriumisreachedwhensy=(n+d)k.FromY=K1/2N1/2==>Y/N=K1/2N-1/2==>y=k1/2==>sk1/2=(n+d)k==>k-1/2=(n+d)/s=(0.07+0.03)/(.2)=1/2==>k1/2=2=y==>k=4.8.a.Iftechnologicalprogressoccurs,thenthelevelofoutputpercapitaforanygivencapital-laborratioincreases.Thefunctiony=f(k)increasestoy=g(k),andthusthesavingsfunctionincreasesfromsf(k)tosg(k).yg(k)y2f(k)12(n+d)ksg(k)y1sf(k)0k1k2k8.b.Sinceg(k)>f(k),itfollowsthatsg(k)>sf(k)foreachlevelofk.Thereforetheintersectionofthesg(k)-curvewiththe(n+d)k-lineisatahigherlevelofk.Thenewsteady-stateequilibriumwillnowbeatahigherlevelofsavingandoutputpercapita,andatahighercapital-laborratio.31n8.c.Afterthetechnologicalprogressoccurs,thelevelofsavingandinvestmentwillincreaseuntilanewandhigheroptimalcapital-laborratioisreached.Theratioofinvestmenttocapitalwillalsoincreaseinthetransitionperiod,sincemorehastobeinvestedtoreachthehigheroptimalcapital-laborratio.kk2k10t1t2t9.TheCobb-DouglasproductionfunctionisdefinedasY=F(N,K)=AN1-qKq.ThemarginalproductoflaborcanthenbederivedasMPN=(DY)/(DN)=(1-q)AN-qKq=(1-q)AN1-qKq/N==(1-q)(Y/N)==>labor'sshareofincome=[MPN*(N)]/Y=(1-q)(Y/N)*[(N)/(Y)]=(1-q)CHAPTER4GROWTHANDPOLICYSolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbookConceptualProblems:1.Endogenousorself-sustainedgrowthsupposedlycanbeachievedbypoliciesthataffectanation'ssavingsrateandthereforetheproportionofGDPthatgoestowardsinvestment.TheneoclassicalgrowthmodelofChapter3predictedthatlong-termgrowthcanonlybeachievedthroughtechnologicalprogressandthatchangesinthesavingsratehaveonlytransitoryeffects.Theendogenousgrowthmodel,however,predictsthatcountrieswithahighersavingsratecanachievehigherlong-termgrowthandthatanation'sgovernmentcanaffectthelong-termgrowthratebyimplementingpoliciesthataffectthesavingsrate.2.Asimplemodelwithconstantreturnstoscaletocapitalaloneimpliesincreasingreturnstoscaletoallfactorstakentogether,whichcouldcauseasinglelargefirmtodominatetheeconomy.However,suchamodelignoresthepossibilitythatexternalreturnstocapitalexist,inadditiontotheinternal(private)returns.Inotherwords,moreinvestmentnotonlyleadstoahigherandmoreefficientcapitalstockbutalsotonewideasandnewwaysofdoingthings,whichcanthenbecopiedbyothers.Therefore,asinglefirmdoesnotnecessarilyreapallofthebenefitsofincreasedoutput.3.Intheneoclassicalgrowthmodel,anincreaseinthesavingsratedoesnotincreasethelong-termgrowthrateofoutput.However,becauseoftheshort-runadjustmentprocess,thereissometransitionalgainthatwillleadtoahigherlevelofoutputpercapita.Intheendogenousgrowthmodel,however,thesavingsratedoesaffectthelong-termgrowthrateofoutput.4.a.Chapter4suggeststhatthekeytolong-termeconomicgrowthisinvestmentinhumanandphysicalcapitalwithparticularemphasisonresearchanddevelopment.4.b.(i)Investmenttaxcreditsmaypotentiallyaffecteconomicgrowthinthelongrunbyachievingahigherrateoftechnologicalprogress.31n(ii)R&Dsubsidiesandgrantsleadtotechnologicaladvancesthatwillhaveprivateandsocialreturns.Theyareveryeffectiveinstimulatinglong-termeconomicgrowth.(iii)Accordingtotheendogenousgrowthmodel,policiesdesignedtoincreasethesavingsratewillincreasethelong-termgrowthrateofoutput.However,empiricalevidencedoesnotlendmuchsupporttothatnotion.(iv)Increasedfundingforprimaryeducationhaslargeprivateandsocialreturnsandisthereforeanexcellentmeanstostimulatelong-termgrowth,eventhoughitmaytakealongtimeuntilthesepolicieshavetheirfulleffect.5.Thenotionofabsoluteconvergencestatesthateconomieswiththesamesavingsrateandrateofpopulationgrowthwillreachthesamesteady-stateequilibriumiftheyhaveaccesstothesametechnology.Thenotionofconditionalconvergencestatesthateconomiesthathaveaccesstothesametechnologyandthesamerateofpopulationgrowthbutdifferentsavingsrateswillreachsteady-stateequilibriaatadifferentlevelofoutputbutthesameeconomicgrowthrate.Thereisempiricalevidencetosupportthenotionofconditionalconvergenceacrosscountries.6.Endogenousgrowththeoryassumesthatthesteady-stategrowthrateofoutputisaffectedbytherateatwhichthefactorsofproductionareaccumulated.Therefore,anincreaseinthesavingsratewouldincreasetherateatwhichthecapitalstockisaccumulatedandthiswouldincreasethegrowthrateofoutput.Whilethisnotionmaybeimportantinexplainingthegrowthratesofhighlydevelopedcountriesattheleadingedgeoftechnology,itcannotexplainthedifferencesingrowthratesacrosspoorercountries.Forthesecountries,thenotionofconditionalconvergenceseemstohold.7.Investinginphysicalcapitalwillleadtoahighercapitalstockandtoahigherlevelofoutputintheshortrun,butoftentothedetrimentoflong-termgrowthunlesstherearesignificantexternalreturnstocapital.Therefore,investinginhumancapitalisabetterstrategy,sinceithashighreturnsandleadstoanincreaseinlong-termgrowth.8.a.Acountrythatisabletochooseitsrateofpopulationgrowththroughpopulationcontrolpoliciescanshifttheinvestmentrequirementdown,therebyincreasingthelevelofsteady-stateoutput.Withalowerrateofpopulationgrowthitispossibletoachieveahigherlevelofincomepercapitawithalowerlevelofinvestmentspending.Therefore,implementingpopulationcontrolpoliciesmaybeaneffectivewaytoescapetheso-calledpovertytrap.8.b.Inanendogenousgrowthmodel,alowerpopulationgrowthrate(n)willincreaseanation'slong-termgrowthrate(Dy/y).Wecanseethissince,inthesecondoptionalsection,theper-capitagrowthratewasderived,asfollows:Dy/y=sa-(n+d).31n9.TheAsianTigers(HongKong,Singapore,SouthKorea,andTaiwan)experiencedahighrateofeconomicgrowthbetween1966and1990byconcentratingonimprovingtheeducationofthepopulationandincreasingthesavingsrate,assuggestedbytheendogenousgrowthmodel.However,increasesinthelaborforcesofthesecountriessuggestedbytheneoclassicalgrowthmodel,werealsoatwork.10.ThedeclineinlivingstandardsexperiencedbyEasternEuropeancountriesintransitionfromcentrallyplannedeconomiestofreemarketeconomiescannoteasilybeexplainedbyneoclassicalorendogenousgrowththeory.ThedeclineinGDPinthesecountrieswaslargelyduetodisorganizedmarketsthatlackedproperlyassignedpropertyrightsorliabilityrulesandaninsufficientlydevelopedbankingsystem.Inaddition,theneedforlarge-scalereplacementofoutdatedproductiontechnologycausedfurtherdisruption.11.Inisunclearwhethercountriescanactuallyexperienceindefiniteincreasesintheirgrowthpotential.However,iftechnologicaladvancesoccurcontinuouslyandifintelligentresourcemanagementispracticed,itisconceivablethateconomicgrowthwillcontinueforavery,verylongtime.TechnicalProblems:1.a.Aproductionfunctionthatdisplaysbothadiminishingandaconstantmarginalproductofcapitalcanbedisplayedbydrawingacurvedline(asinanexogenousgrowthmodel),followedbyaupward-slopingline(asinanendogenousgrowthmodel).Suchagraphisdepictedbelow.1.b.Thefirstequilibrium(PointAinthegraphbelow)isastablelow-incomesteady-stateequilibrium.Anydeviationfromthatpointwillcausetheeconomytoeventuallyadjustagainatthesamesteady-stateincomelevel(andcapital-outputratio).Thesecondequilibrium(PointB)isanunstablehigh-incomesteady-stateequilibrium.Anydeviationfromthatpointwillleadtoeitheralowerincomesteady-stateequilibrium(ifthecapital-laborratiodeclines)orongoinggrowth(ifthecapital-laborratioincreases).yy=f(k)yBsyB(n+d)kyAA31n0kAkBk1.c.Amodelliketheoneinthisquestioncanbeusedtoexplainhowsomecountriescanfindthemselvesinasituationwithnogrowthandlowincomewhileothershaveongoinggrowthandahighlevelofincome.Inthefirstcase,acountrymayhaveinvestedinphysicalcapital,leadingtosomeshort-termgrowthattheexpenseoflong-termgrowth,whereasinthesecondcase,acountrymayhaveinvestedheavilyinhumancapital,reapingsignificantsocialreturns.2.a.Ifpopulationgrowthisendogenous,thatis,ifacountrycaninfluencetherateofpopulationgrowththroughgovernmentpolicies,thentheinvestmentrequirementisnolongerastraightline.Insteaditiscurvedasdepictedbelow.yyCy=f(k)yB[n(y)+d]]kCsf(k)yABA0kAkBkCk2.b.Thefirstequilibrium(PointA)isastablesteady-stateequilibrium.Itisasituationoflowincomeandhighpopulationgrowth,indicatingthatthecountryisinapovertytrap.Thesecondequilibrium(PointB)isanunstablesteady-stateequilibrium.Itisasituationofmediumincomeandlowpopulationgrowth.Thethirdequilibrium(PointC)isastablesteady-stateequilibrium.Itisasituationofhighincomeandlowpopulationgrowth.Noneofthesethreeequilibriahaveongoinggrowth.2.c.Toescapethepovertytrap(PointA),acountryhasseveralpossibilities:First,itcansomehowfindthemeanstoincreasethecapital-laborratioabovealevelconsistentwithPointB(perhapsbyborrowingfundsorseekingdirectforeigninvestment).Second,itcanincreasethesavingsratesuchthatthesavingsfunctionnolongerintersectstheinvestmentrequirementcurveateitherPointAorPointB.Third,itcandecreasetherateofpopulationgrowththroughspecificallydesignedpolicies,suchthattheinvestmentrequirementshiftsdownandnolongerintersectswiththesavingsfunctionatPointAorPointB.3.a.Ifweincorporateendogenouspopulationgrowthintoatwo-sectormodelinProblem2,thenwegetacurvedlinefortheinvestmentrequirementlineandaproductionfunctionwithfirstadiminishingand31nthenaconstantmarginalproductofcapitalasdepictedbelow.(Notethatthesavingsfunctionhasthesameshapeastheproductionfunction.)yy=f(k)yDsf(k)D[n+d)]kyCyByACBA0kAkBkCkDk3.b.Thereshouldbefourintersectionsofthesavingsfunctionandtheinvestmentrequirement.Thefirstequilibrium(atPointA)isastablelow-incomesteady-stateequilibrium.Anydeviationfromthatpointwillcausetheeconomytoeventuallyadjustagainatthesamesteady-stateincomelevel(andcapital-outputratio).Thesecondequilibrium(atPointB)isanunstablelow-incomeequilibrium.Anydeviationfromthatpointwillleadtoeitheralowerincomesteady-stateequilibriumatPointA(ifthecapital-laborratiodeclines)orahigherincomesteady-stateequilibriumatPointC(ifthecapital-laborratioincreases).PointDisagainanunstableequilibriumbutatahighlevelofincome.Anydeviationfromthatpointwillleadtoeitheralowerincomesteady-stateequilibriumatPointC(ifthecapital-laborratiodeclines)orongoinggrowth(ifthecapital-laborratioincreases).3.c.Thismodelismoreinclusivethaneitherofthetwomodelsdiscussedpreviously,andthereforehasgreaterexplanatorypower.Butnowthegraphicalanalysisisfarmorecomplicated.Itmaynotbeworththeefforttointroducesuchcomplications.4.a.TheproductionfunctionisoftheformY=K1/2(AN)1/2=K1/2(4[K/N]N)1/2=K1/2(4K)1/2=2K4.b.Sincea=y/k=2,itfollowsthatthegrowthrateofoutputisg=sa-(n+d)=(0.1)2-(0.02+0.03)=0.15=15%.4.c.Theterm"a"intheequationabovestandsforthemarginalproductofcapital.Ifweassumethattheleveloflabor-augmentingtechnology(A)isproportionaltothecapital-laborratio(k),weimplythattheleveloftechnologydependsontheamountofcapitalperworkerthatwehave,whichmaynotberealistic.4.d.Inthismodel,wehaveaconstantmarginalproductofcapital,andthereforewehaveanendogenousgrowthmodel.31n5.a.TheproductionfunctionisoftheformY=K1/2N1/2==>Y/N=(K/N)1/2==>y=k1/2.Fromk=sy/(n+d)=sk1/2/(n+d)==>k1/2=s/(n+d)==>y*=s/(n+d)=(0.1)/(0.02+0.03)=2==>k*=sy*/(n+d)=(0.1)(2)/(0.02+0.03)=45.b.Steady-stateconsumptionequalssteady-stateincomeminussteady-stateinvestment,thatis,c*=f(k*)-(n+d)k*.Thegoldenrulecapitalstockcorrespondstothehighestpermanentlysustainablelevelofconsumption.Steady-stateconsumptionismaximizedwhenthemarginalincreaseincapitalproducesjustenoughextraoutputtocovertheincreasedinvestmentrequirement.Fromc=k1/2-(n+d)k==>(Dc/Dk)=(1/2)k-1/2-(n+d)=0==>k-1/2=2(n+d)=2(.02+.03)=.1==>k1/2=10==>k=100Sincek*=4<100,wehavelesscapitalatthesteadystatethanthegoldenrulesuggests.5.c.Fromk=sy/(n+d)=sk1/2/(n+d)==>s=k1/2(n+d)=10(0.05)=.55.d.Ifwehavemorecapitalthanthegoldenrulesuggests,thenwearesavingtoomuchandwedonothavetheoptimalamountofconsumption.Chapter5SolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbookConceptualProblems:1.Theaggregatesupplycurveshowsthequantityofrealtotaloutputthatfirmsarewillingtosupplyateachpricelevel.Theaggregatedemandcurveshowsallcombinationsofrealtotaloutputandthepricelevelatwhichthegoodsandthemoneysectorsaresimultaneouslyinequilibrium.AlongtheAD-curvenominalmoneysupplyisassumedtobeconstantandnofiscalpolicychangetakesplace.2.Theclassicalaggregatesupplycurveisvertical,sincetheclassicalmodelassumesthatnominalwagesadjustveryquicklytochangesinthepricelevel.Thisimpliesthatthelabormarketisalwaysinequilibriumandoutputisalwaysatthefull-employmentlevel.IftheAD-curveshiftstotheright,firmstrytoincreaseoutputbyhiringmoreworkers,whotheytrytoattractbyofferinghighernominalwages.Butsincewearealreadyatfullemployment,nomoreworkerscanbehiredandfirmsmerelybidupnominalwages.Thenominalwageincreaseispassedonintheformofhigherproductprices.Intheend,thelevelofwagesandpriceswillhaveincreasedproportionally,whiletherealwagerateandthelevelsofemploymentandoutputwillremainunchanged.Ifthereisadecreaseindemand,thenfirmstrytolayoffworkers.Workers,inturn,arewillingtoacceptlowerwagestostayemployed.Lowerwagecostsenablefirmstolowertheirproductprices.Intheend,nominalwagesandpriceswilldecreaseproportionallybuttherealwagerateandthelevelofemploymentandoutputwillremainthesame.3.Thereisnosingletheoryoftheaggregatesupplycurve,whichshowstherelationshipbetweenfirms'outputandthepricelevel.Anumberofcompetingexplanationsexistforthefactthatfirmshaveatendencytoincreasetheiroutputlevelasthepricelevelincreases.TheKeynesianmodelofahorizontalaggregatesupplycurvesupposedlydescribestheveryshortrun(overaperiodofafewmonthsorless),whiletheclassicalmodelofaverticalaggregatesupplycurveissupposedtoholdtrueforthelongrun(aperiodofmorethan10years).Themedium-runaggregatesupplycurveismostusefulforperiodsofseveralquartersorafewyears.Thisupward-slopingaggregatesupplycurveresultsfromthefactthatwageandpriceadjustmentsareslowanduncoordinated.Chapter6offersseveralexplanationsforthefactthatlabormarketsdonotadjustquickly.Theseincludethe31nimperfectinformationmarket-clearingmodel,theexistenceofwagecontractsorcoordinationproblems,andthefactthatfirmspayefficiencywagesandpricechangestendtobecostly.4.TheKeynesianaggregatesupplycurveishorizontalsincethepricelevelisassumedtobefixed.Itismostappropriatefortheveryshortrun(aperiodofafewmonthsorless).Theclassicalaggregatesupplycurveisverticalandoutputisassumedtobefixedatitspotentiallevel.Itismostappropriateforthelongrun(aperiodofmorethan10years)whenpricesareabletofullyadjusttoallshocks.5.Theaggregatesupplyandaggregatedemandmodelusedinmacroeconomicsisnotverysimilartothemarketdemandandmarketsupplymodelusedinmicroeconomics.Whiletheworkingsofbothmodels(thedistinctionbetweenshiftsofthecurvesversusmovementalongthecurves)aresimilar,thesemodelsarereallyunrelated.The"P"inthemicroeconomicmodelstandsfortherelativepriceofagood(ortheratioatwhichtwogoodsaretraded),whereasthe"P"inthemacroeconomicmodelstandsfortheaveragepricelevelofallgoodsandservicesproducedinthiscountry,measuredinmoneyterms.TechnicalProblems:1.a.AsFigure5-9inthetextshows,adecreaseinincometaxeswillshiftboththeAD-curveandtheAS-curvetotheright.TheshiftintheAD-curvetendstobefairlylargeand,intheshortrun(whenpricesarefixed),leadstoasignificantincreaseinoutputwithoutachangeinprices.Inthelongrun,theAS-curvewillalsoshifttotheright--sincelowerincometaxratesprovideanincentivetoworkmore--butonlybyafairlysmallamount.ThereforeweseeaslightlyhigherrealGDPwithalargeincreaseinthepricelevelinthelongrun.1.b.Supply-sideeconomicsisanypolicymeasurethatwillincreasepotentialGDPbyshiftingthelong-run(vertical)AS-curvetotheright.Intheearly1980s,supply-sideeconomistsputforththeviewthatacutinincometaxrateswouldincreasetheincentivetowork,saveandinvest.Thiswouldincreaseaggregatesupplysomuchthattheinflationandunemploymentrateswouldsimultaneouslydecrease.Theresultinghigheconomicgrowthmightthenevenleadtoanincreaseintaxrevenues,despitelowertaxrates.However,thesepredictionsdidnotbecomereality.Asseenintheanswerto2.a.,thelong-runeffectofataxcutonoutputisnotverylarge,althoughitcanincreaselong-termoutputtosomedegree.2.a.Accordingtothebalancedbudgettheorem,asimultaneousandequalincreaseingovernmentpurchasesandtaxeswillshifttheAD-curvetotheright.ButiftheAS-curveisupwardsloping,thenthebalancedbudgetmultiplierwillbelessthanone,thatis,theincreaseinoutputwillbelessthantheincreaseingovernmentexpenditures.Thisoccurs,sincepartoftheincreaseingovernmentspendingwillbecrowdedoutdueahigherpricelevel,lowerrealmoneybalances,andaresultingriseininterestrates.PADoAD1ASPoP1031nYoY1Y2.b.IntheKeynesiancase,theAS-curveishorizontalandthepricelevelremainsunchanged.Thereisnorealbalanceeffectandthereforeincomewillincreasemorethanin3.a.However,theinterestratewillstillincreaseandthereforethebalancedbudgetmultiplierwillbelessthanone(butgreaterthanzero).PADoAD1PoAS0YoY1Y2.c.Intheclassicalcase,theAS-curveisverticalandtheoutputlevelremainsunchanged.Inthiscase,ashiftintheAD-curveleadstoapriceincreaseandrealmoneybalancesdecline.Thereforeinterestratesincreasefurtherthanin3.b.,leadingtofullcrowdingoutofinvestment.Hencethebalancedbudgetmultiplieriszero.PAD1ASAD0P1P00Y*YAdditionalProblems1.BrieflyexplainwhytheAS-curveisupwardslopingintheintermediaterun?Anupward-slopingAS-curveassumesthatwageandpriceadjustmentsareslowanduncoordinated.Thiscanbeexplainedmosteasilybytheexistenceofwagecontractsandimperfectcompetition.Becauseofwagecontracts,wagescannotbechangedeasilyand,sincethecontractstendtobestaggered,theycannotbechangedallatonce.Inanimperfectlycompetitivemarketstructure,firmsarereluctanttochangetheirpricessincetheycannotaccuratelypredictthereactionsoftheircompetitors.Therefore,wagesandpriceswilladjustonlyslowly.(Chapter6providesmoreelaborateexplanationsforthis.)2.BrieflydiscussinwordswhytheAD-curveisdownwardsloping.IntheAD-ASframework,weassumethatnominalmoneysupply(M)isconstantunlessitischangedbytheFed'smonetarypolicy(whichwouldresultinashiftintheAD-curve).Therefore,ifthepricelevelincreases,thenrealmoney(M/P)decreases,drivinginterestrates(i)upandloweringthelevelofinvestmentspending(I).Thismeansthattotaloutputdemanded(Y)willdecrease.31nAmoreelaborateanswermayincludethatlowerrealmoneybalances(M/P)resultinlessrealwealth,leadingtoalowerlevelofconsumption(C)duetothewealtheffect.Thismeansthattotaloutputdemanded(Y)willdecrease.Ahigherdomesticpricelevel(P)alsomeansthatdomesticgoodswillbecomelesscompetitiveinworldmarkets.Thiswillstimulateimportswhilereducingexports,leadingtoareductioninnetexports(NX),andadecreaseintotaloutputdemanded(Y).3."Intheclassicalaggregatesupplycurvemodel,theeconomyisalwaysatthefull-employmentlevelofoutputandtheunemploymentrateisalwayszero."Commentonthisstatement.TheclassicalaggregatesupplycurvemodelimpliesaverticalAS-curveatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput.However,thisdoesnotmeanthattheunemploymentrateiszero.Thereisalwayssomefrictioninthelabormarket,whichmeansthatthereisalwayssome(frictional)unemploymentasworkersswitchjobs.The(positive)amountofunemploymentatthefull-employmentlevelofoutputiscalledthenaturalrateofunemploymentandisestimatedtoberoughly5.5percentfortheUnitedStates;however,anexactvalueforthisnaturalratehasnotbeenestablished.4.Assumeatechnologicaladvanceleadstolowerproductioncosts.Showtheeffectofsuchaneventonnationalincome,unemployment,inflation,andinterestrateswiththehelpofanAD-ASdiagram,assumingcompletelyflexiblewagerates.AdecreaseinproductioncostsshiftstheAS-curvetotheright.Thepriceleveldecreases,leadingtoahigherlevelofincomeandlowerinterestrates.Sincewagesarecompletelyflexible,theAS-curveisverticalandwearealwaysatfull-employment(thisistheclassicalcase).Thisimpliesthattheunemploymentratestaysatthenaturalrate,butoutputgoesupsinceworkersarenowmoreproductive.1.®2.Costofprod.==>AS®Ex.S.==>P¯realmsi¯IYEffect:YUR¯P¯i¯PASoAS1Po31nP1AD0YoFEY1FEY5."MonetaryexpansionwillnotchangeinterestratesintheclassicalAS-curvemodel."Commentonthisstatement.AnincreaseinthenominalmoneysupplywillshifttheAD-curvetotheright.Therewillbeexcessdemandforgoodsandservices,whichwillforcethepricelevelup.IntheclassicalAS-curvemodel,anewequilibriumwillbeestablishedatthesamelevelofoutputbutatahigherpricelevel.Realmoneybalanceswillbereducedtotheiroriginallevelandinterestrateswillnotbeaffectedinthelongrun(theclassicalcase).6."ExpansionaryfiscalpolicydoesnotaffectthelevelofrealoutputorrealmoneybalancesintheclassicalAS-curvecase."Commentonthisstatement.ExpansionaryfiscalpolicywillshifttheAD-curvetotheright,causingexcessdemandforgoodsandservicesattheexistingpricelevel.Thisforcesthepricelevelup,reducingrealmoneybalances.Interestratesincrease,whichresultsinalowerlevelofinvestmentspending.Intheclassicalcase,theAS-curveisvertical,sothelevelofoutputwillnotchange.Inotherwords,theincreaseinthelevelofpricesandinterestratescontinuesuntilprivatespendingisreducedagaintotheoriginalfull-employmentlevel.7."IntheclassicalAS-curvecase,areductioningovernmentspendingwilllowerinterestratesandtherealmoneystock."Commentonthisstatement.AdecreaseingovernmentspendingwillshifttheAD-curvetotheleft,causingexcesssupplyofgoodsandservicesattheoriginalpricelevel.Asthepriceleveldecreasestorestoreequilibrium,realmoneybalancesincreaseandinterestratesfall.Thiswillincreasethelevelofinvestmentspendinguntilanewequilibriumisreachedattheoriginallevelofoutputbutatlowerpricesandinterestrates.Thus,realmoneybalanceswillrise,butinterestratesfall.8."IntheKeynesianaggregatesupplycurvemodel,theFed,throughrestrictivemonetarypolicy,caneasilylowerinflationwithoutcreatingunemployment."Commentonthisstatement.Thisstatementiswrong.IntheKeynesianaggregatesupplycurvemodel,theAS-curveishorizontal,sincepricesareassumedtobefixed.RestrictivemonetarypolicywillshifttheAD-curvetotheleft.Thiswillreducethelevelofoutputwithoutanychangeinthepricelevel.Butalowerlevelofoutputimpliesahigherrateofunemployment.9.Trueorfalse?Why?"MonetarypolicydoesnotaffectrealoutputintheKeynesiansupplycurvemodel."False.AnincreaseinmoneysupplywillshifttheAD-curvetotheright,leadingtoahigherlevelofincome.IntheKeynesiansupplycurvemodel,thepricelevelisfixed,hencerealbalanceswillnot31nfallastheywouldintheclassicalsupplycurvemodel.Wewillreachanewequilibriumatahigherlevelofoutput,atalowerinterestrate,butatthesamepricelevel.Inthiscasemonetarypolicyisnotneutral.10.ExplainwhythereissomuchinterestinfindingwaystoshifttheAS-curvetotheright.ShiftingtheAS-curvetotherightseemstobetheonlywaytooffsettheeffectsofanadversesupplyshockwithoutnegativesideeffects.Anadversesupplyshock,suchasanincreaseinoilprices,causesasimultaneousincreaseinunemploymentandinflation,andpolicymakershaveonlytwooptionsfordemand-managementpolicies.Expansionaryfiscalormonetarypolicywillhelptoachievefullemploymentfasterbutwillraisethepricelevel,whilerestrictivefiscalormonetarypolicywillreduceinflationarypressurebutincreaseunemployment.Therefore,anypolicythatwouldshifttheshort-runAS-curvebacktotherightseemspreferable,sinceitmightbringtheeconomybacktotheoriginalequilibriumbysimultaneouslyloweringinflationandunemployment.11."Restrictivefiscalpolicywillalwaysloweroutput,prices,andinterestrates."Comment.ThisstatementistrueintheintermediaterunwhentheAS-curveisupwardsloping.RestrictivefiscalpolicywillshifttheAD-curvetotheleft.IntheKeynesiancase,theAS-curveishorizontalandpricesremainconstant,whilebothoutputandinterestratesdecrease.Intheclassicalcase,theAS-curveisverticalandthedecreaseinthepricelevelwillincreaserealmoneybalancesandinterestrates.Priceswillfalluntilspendingisagainconsistentwiththefull-employmentlevelofoutput.Thusinthelongrun,pricesandinterestrateswilldecline,whileoutputwillremainthesame.Onlyintheintermediaterun(whentheAS-curveisupwardslopingduetoslowlyadjustingwagesandprices)willoutput,prices,andtheinterestrateallgodown.12."Therealimpactofdemandmanagementpolicyislargelydeterminedbytheflexibilityofwagesandprices."Commentonthisstatement.Ifwagesandpricesarecompletelyflexible,thentheeconomywillalwaysbeatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput,independentofthepricelevel.Inotherwords,wehavetheclassicalcaseofavertical(long-run)AS-curve.Inthiscase,ashiftintheAD-curvewillaffectonlythepricelevelbutnotthelevelofoutput.However,ifwagesandpricesarecompletelyinflexible,thenwehavethe(horizontal)Keynesianaggregatesupplycurve.Inthiscase,anyshiftoftheAD-curvewillhavealargeeffectonthelevelofoutputbutwillnotaffectthepricelevel.Onlyintheintermediaterun,whenwehaveanupward-slopingAS-curve,willthelevelofoutputandthepricelevelbothbeaffectedbyashiftintheAD-curve.MoreflexibilityinwagesandpricesimpliesasteepertheAS-curve.ThereforetheeffectofashiftintheAD-curvewillbesmalleronoutputandlargeronthepricelevel.13."Anincreaseintheincometaxratewilllowerthelevelofoutputandincreasethepricelevel."Commentonthisstatement.SupplysidersarguethatadecreaseinincometaxeswillshiftboththeAD-curveandtheAS-curvetotheright(asshowninFigure5-10).Conversely,anincreaseintheincometaxratewillshifttheAD-curveandtheAS-curvetotheleft.TheshiftintheAD-curvewillbefairlylargeand,inthemediumrun,willleadtoasignificantdecreaseinoutputwithouta(significant)changeinthepricelevel.However,inthelongrun,theAS-curvewillalsoshifttotheleft,sincehigherincometaxratesprovideadisincentiveto31nwork.SincetheAS-curvewillshiftonlybyafairlysmallamount,wewillseeaslightlylowerrealGDPwithalargedecreaseinthepricelevel.Chapter6SolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbook:ConceptualProblems:1.TheaggregatesupplycurveandthePhillipscurvedescribeverysimilarrelationshipsandbothcurvescanbeusedtoanalyzethesamephenomena.TheAS-curveshowsarelationshipbetweenthepricelevelandthelevelofoutput.ThePhillipscurveshowsarelationshipbetweentherateofinflationandtheunemploymentrate,givencertaininflationaryexpectations.Forexample,amovementalongtheAS-curvedepictsanincreaseinthepricelevelthatisassociatedwithanincreaseinthelevelofoutput.Asoutputincreases,therateofunemploymentdecreases(seeOkun’slaw).Therefore,withalargerincreaseinthepricelevel(ahigherlevelofinflation)therewillbeadecreaseinunemployment,creatingadownward-slopingPhillipscurve.ThisdownwardslopingPhillipscurveshiftswheneverinflationaryexpectationschange.Ifoneassumesthatworkerswillchangetheirwagedemandswhenevertheirinflationaryexpectationschange,onecanconcludethatashiftinthePhillipscurvecorrespondstoashiftintheupwardslopingAS-curve,sincehigherwagesmeanhighercostofproduction.2.Intheshortrun,whenwagesandpricesareassumedtobefixed,therecanbenoinflationandthusthePhillipscurvemakesnosenseoverthisverybrieftimeframe.Butinthemediumrun(inthischapteralsooftenreferredtoastheshortrun),thePhillipscurveisdownwardslopingasinflationaryexpectationsareassumedtobeconstant.Inthelongrun,thePhillipscurveisverticalatthenaturalrateofunemployment,whichcorrespondstotheverticallong-runAS-curveatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput.3.Avarietyofexplanationsaregiveninthischapterforthestickinessofwagesintheshortorintermediaterun.Oneisthatworkershaveimperfectinformationandnobodyknowstheactualpricelevel.Peopledon’tknowwhetherachangeintheirnominalwageistheresultofanincreaseinpricesorintherealwagetheyreceivefortheworktheyprovide.Duetothisuncertainty,labormarketswillnotclearimmediately.Anotherargumentreliesoncoordinationproblems,thatis,differentfirmswithinaneconomycannotcoordinatepricechangesinresponsetomonetarypolicychanges.Individualfirmschangetheirpricesonlyreluctantly,sincetheyareafraidoflosingmarketshare.Theefficiencywagetheoryarguesthatemployerspayabovemarket-clearingwagestomotivatetheirworkerstoworkharder.Firmsarealsoreluctanttochangewagesbecauseoftheperceivedmenucostsinvolved.Therearelong-termrelationsbetweenfirmsandworkersandwagesareusuallysetinnominaltermsbywagecontracts,whicharerenegotiatedonlyperiodically.Thusrealwagesfluctuateovertimeasthepricelevelchanges.Finally,theinsider-outsidermodelarguesthatfirmsnegotiateonlywiththeirownemployeesbutnotwithunemployedworkers.Sinceaturnoverinthelaborforce31niscostlytofirms,theyarewillingtoofferabovemarket-clearingwagestothecurrentlyemployedratherthanhiringtheunemployedwhomaybewillingtoworkforlowerwages.Thesedifferentviewsarenotnecessarilymutuallyexclusiveanditisuptostudentstodecidewhichoftheargumentspresentedheretheyfindmostplausible.Theexplanationsdiffermainlyintheirassumptionofhowfastmarketsclearandwhetheremploymentvariationsarevoluntary.4.a.Stagflationisdefinedasaperiodofhighunemploymentaccompaniedbyhighinflation.4.b.Stagflationcanoccurintimeperiodswhenpeoplehavehighinflationaryexpectations.Iftheeconomygoesintoarecession,theactualrateofinflationwillfallbelowtheexpectedrateofinflation.However,theactualinflationratemaystillbeveryhighwhiletherateofunemploymentisincreasing.Forexample,theFedmayhaveletmoneysupplygrowmuchtoofastinthepast,soeveryoneexpectsahighinflationrate.Ifasupplyshockoccurs,wewillseeanincreaseintherateofunemploymentwhileinflationaryexpectationsandactualinflationremainveryhigh.Thisscenariooccurredduringthe1970s.Oncewehavereachedsuchasituation,itbecomesnecessarytodesignpoliciesthatwillreduceinflationaryexpectationstoshiftthePhillipscurvebacktotheleft.5.AssumeadisturbanceoccursandtheAD-curveshiftstotheright.Unemploymentdecreasesandinflationincreases,andwemovealongthedownwardslopingPhillipscurvetotheleft.However,assoonaspeoplerealizethatactualinflationishigherthantheirinflationaryexpectations,theyadjusttheirinflationaryexpectationsupwardandthedownward-slopingPhillipscurveshiftstotheright,eventuallyreturningunemployment31nbacktoitsnaturalrate.Inotherwords,theeconomyadjustsbackatthefull-employmentlevelofincome.Ifanadversesupplyshockoccurs(theupward-slopingAS-curveshiftstotheleft),unemploymentandinflationincreasesimultaneously.Thiswillcorrespondtoashiftofthedownward-slopingPhillipscurvetotheright.However,whenpeoplerealizethatactualinflationislessthanexpectedinflation,thenthedownward-slopingPhillipscurvestartstoshiftbackandtheeconomyadjustsbacktothenaturalrateofunemploymentinthelongrun.6.Theexpectations-augmentedPhillipscurvepredictsthatinflationwillriseabovetheexpectedlevelwhenunemploymentdropsbelowitsnaturalrate.However,ifpeopleknowthatthisisgoingtohappen,whydon’ttheyimmediatelyadjusttoit?Andifpeopleimmediatelyadjustedtoit,wouldn’tthisimplythatanticipatedmonetarypolicywouldbeineffectivetocauseanydeviationfromthefull-employmentlevelofoutput?Inreality,however,evenifpeoplehaverationalexpectations,theymaynotbeabletoadjustimmediately.Onereasonisthatwagecontractsoftensetwagesforanextendedtimeperiod.Similarly,pricescannotalwaysbechangedrightawayandthecostsofchangingpricesmayoutweighthebenefits.Afurtherargumentisthatevenrationalpeoplemakeforecastingmistakesandlearnonlyslowly.Inotherwords,thelocationoftheexpectations-augmentedPhillipscurveisdeterminedbythelevelofexpectedinflation,whichissetbyrecenthistoricalexperience.Ashiftinthiscurvecausedbychanginginflationaryexpectationsoccursonlygradually.Therationalexpectationsmodel,ontheotherhand,assumesthatthePhillipscurveshiftsalmostinstantaneouslyasnewinformationaboutthenearfuturebecomesavailable.TechnicalProblems:1.Areductioninthesupplyofmoneyleadstoexcessdemandformoneyandincreasedinterestrates,reducingthelevelofprivatespending(especiallyinvestment).ThereforetheAD-curveshiftstotheleft.Thiscausesanexcesssupplyofgoodsandservicesattheoriginalpricelevelsothepricelevelstartstodecrease.SincetheAS-curveisupwardsloping,anewshort-runmacro-equilibriumisreachedatalowerlevelofoutput(andthusahigherlevelofunemployment)andalowerpricelevel.PAD1AS1AS2AD231nP11P22P230Y1Y*YHowever,thehigherlevelofunemploymenteventuallyputsdownwardpressureonwages,reducingthecostofproductionandshiftingtheupward-slopingAS-curvetotheright.Alternatively,sincethisequilibriumoutputlevelisbelowthefull-employmentlevel,priceswillcontinuetofall,andtheupward-slopingAS-curvewillshifttotheright.Aslongasoutputisbelowthefull-employmentlevelY*,theupward-slopingAS-curvewillcontinuetoshifttotheright,whichmeansthatthepricelevelwillcontinuetodecline.Eventuallyanewlong-runequilibriumwillbereachedatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput(Y*)andalowerpricelevel.2.Accordingtotherationalexpectationstheory,anannouncedchangeinmonetarypolicywouldimmediatelychangepeople’sperceptioninregardtotheexpectedinflationrate.Ifpeoplecouldadjustimmediatelytothischangeininflationaryexpectations,thentherateofunemploymentortheoutputlevelwouldremainthesame.Inotherwords,wewouldimmediatelymovefrompoint1topoint3inthediagramusedtoexplainthepreviousquestionandtheFedwouldbeunabletoaffecttheunemploymentrate.Inreality,however,evenifpeoplehaverationalexpectationsandcananticipatetheeffectsofapolicychangecorrectly,theymaynotbeabletoimmediatelyadjustduetowagecontracts,etc.Thus,therewillalwaysbesomedeviationfromthefull-employmentoutputlevelY*.3.a.Afavorablesupplyshock,suchasadeclineinmaterialprices,shiftstheupward-slopingAS-curvetotheright,leadingtoexcesssupplyattheexistingpricelevel.Anewshort-runequilibriumisreachedatahigherlevelofoutputandalowerpricelevel.Butsinceoutputisnowabovethefull-employmentlevelY*,thereisupwardpressureonwagesandpricesandtheupward-slopingAS-curveshiftsbacktotheright.Anewlong-runequilibriumisreachedbackattheoriginalposition(Y*),andtheoriginalpricelevel(assumingthatthechangeinmaterialpricesdidnotaffectthefull-employmentlevelofoutput).Sincenominalwages(W)willhaverisenbutthepricelevel(P)willnothavechanged,realwages(W/P)willhaveincreased.31nPADAS1AS231P1P20Y*Y1Y3.b.Lowermaterialpriceslowerthecostofproduction,shiftingtheupward-slopingAS-curveshiftstotheright,andleadingtoanincreaseinoutputandalowerpricelevel.Sinceunemploymentisnowbelowitsnaturalrate,thereisashortageoflabor,providingupwardpressureonwages.Thiswillincreasethecostofproductionagain,eventuallyshiftingtheupward-slopingAS-curvebacktotheoriginallong-runequilibrium(assumingthatpotentialGDPhasnotbeenaffected).AdditionalProblems:1.Explainthelong-runeffectofanincreaseinnominalmoneysupplyontheamountofrealmoneybalancesavailableintheeconomy.Intheveryshortrun,thepricelevelisfixed,soifnominalmoneysupply(M)increases,ahigherlevelofrealmoneybalancesisavailable,causinginterestratestofallandthelevelofinvestmentspendingtoincrease.Thisleadstoanincreaseinaggregatedemand.TheshifttotherightoftheAD-curvecausesthepricelevel(P)toincrease,leadingtoareductioninrealmoneybalances(M/P).Inthemediumrun(anupward-slopingAS-curve),wereachanewequilibriumatahigheroutputlevelandahigherpricelevel.Sincepriceshavegoneupproportionallylessthannominalmoneysupply,realmoneybalanceshaveincreased.However,toreachanewlong-runequilibrium,priceshavetoincreasefurther,andasaresult,thelevelofrealmoneybalanceswilldecreasefurther.Whenthenewlong-runequilibriumatY*isfinallyreached,thepricelevelwillhaverisenproportionallytonominalmoneysupplyandthelevelofrealmoneybalanceswillbebackatitsoriginallevel.2.Assumetheeconomyisinarecession.Describeanadjustmentprocessthatwillensurethattheeconomyeventuallywillreturntofullemployment.Howcanthegovernmentspeedupthisprocess?31nIftheeconomyisinarecession,therewillbedownwardpressureonwagesandprices,whichwillbringtheeconomybacktothefull-employmentoutputlevel.Theupward-slopingAS-curvewillshifttotherightduetolowerproductioncosts.However,thisprocessmaytakeafairlylongtime.Thegovernmentcanshortenthisadjustmentprocesswiththehelpofexpansionaryfiscalormonetarypoliciestostimulateaggregatedemand.TheresultingshifttotherightoftheAD-curveimpliesthatthefinallong-runequilibriumwillbeatahigherpricelevel.Inotherwords,thereductioninunemploymentcanonlybeachievedatthecostofhigherinflation.3."Thestickinessofwagesimpliesthatpolicymakerscanachievelowunemploymentonlyiftheyarewillingtoputupwithhighinflation."Commentonthisstatement.Thereareseveralexplanationsofwhywagesandpricesadjustonlyslowly.Oneisthatworkershaveimperfectinformation,sotheydonotrealizethatlowerpricesmeanhigherrealwages.Anotheristhatfirmsarereluctanttochangepricesandwagessincetheyareunsureaboutthebehavioroftheircompetitorsandwanttoavoidtheperceivedcostofmakingthesechanges.Finally,wagecontractstendtobelong-termandstaggered,soittakestimetoadjustwagestopricechanges.Somefirmsmaypaytheirworkersabovemarket-clearingwagestokeepthemhappyandproductive.Forthesereasons,wagesandpricestendtoberigidintheshortrun.Thusittakestimefortheeconomytoadjustbacktofull-employment.IftherewereastablePhillips-curverelationship,alowrateofunemploymentcouldonlybeachievedbyallowinginflationtoincrease.However,suchastablerelationshipdoesnotexist.Wagestendtoberigidintheshortrun,soexpansionarypolicieslowerunemploymentandincreaseinflationintheshortrun.Inthelongrun,however,theeconomywilladjustbacktothenaturalrateofunemployment,soexpansionarypoliciessimplyleadtoahigherpricelevel.4."Ifweassumethatpeoplehaverationalexpectations,thenfiscalpolicyisalwaysirrelevant.Butmonetarypolicycanstillbeusedtoaffecttherateofinflationandunemployment."Commentonthisstatement.Individualsandfirmswithrationalexpectationsconsistentlymakeoptimaldecisionsbasedonallinformationavailable.Aslongasapolicychangeisanticipated,peopleareabletoassessitslongrunoutcomeandwilltrytoimmediatelyadjust.Sincefiscalpolicydoesn'taffectinflationorunemploymentinthelongrun,itisalsoineffectiveintheshortrunifwagesandpricesareassumedtobeflexible.Ananticipatedchangeinmonetarygrowth,ontheotherhand,willbereflectedinachangeintheinflationrate.Ifwagesareflexible,workerswilladjusttheirwagedemandsimmediatelyandnosignificantchangeintheunemploymentratewilloccur.However,evenifpeoplehaverationalexpectations,wagestendtobefairlyrigidintheshortrunduetowagecontracts.Therefore,itwilltaketimefortheeconomytoadjustbacktoalong-runequilibrium.Thisimpliesthatbothfiscalandmonetarypolicycanaffecttherateofinflationandunemploymenttosomedegreeintheshortrun.5."Inflationcannotaccelerateinarecession,whentherateofunemploymentisaboveitsnaturalrate."Commentonthisstatement.Inflationcanaccelerateeveninarecession,thatis,whentheunemploymentishigh,ifasupplyshockoccurs.Anoilpriceincreasewillincreasethecostofproduction,sotheupward-slopingAS-curvewillshifttotheleft.Thiswillincreasetheinflationrateandtherateofunemploymentsimultaneously,asfirmsincreasetheirproductpricesandcuttheirproduction.IftheFedtriestoaccommodatethesupplyshockwithexpansionarymonetarypolicyinanefforttostimulatetheeconomy,theninflationwillaccelerateevenmore,astheAD-curveshiftstotheright.31n6.Commentonthefollowingstatement:"ThecoordinationapproachtothePhillipscurvefocusesontheproblemsthattheadministrationhasincoordinatingitsfiscalpolicieswiththemonetarypoliciesoftheFed."Thecoordinationapproachhasnothingtodowithfiscalormonetarypolicybutissimplyoneexplanationofwhywagesadjustslowly.Thisviewassertsthatfirmsgenerallyareunabletocoordinatewageandpricechangesinresponsetoamonetarypolicychange.Forexample,anyfirmthatcutsworkers'wagesinresponsetomonetarycontractionwhileotherfirmsdon't,willangeritsemployeeswhomaythenchoosetoleave.Firmsarealsoreluctanttochangetheirpricessincetheyareunsureabouttheircompetitors'behavior.Thuswagesandpriceschangeonlyslowlyinresponsetoachangeinaggregatedemand.Thisimpliesanupward-sloping(short-run)AS-curve.7.Commentonthefollowingstatement:"Theunemploymentrateiszeroatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput."Withahigherpricelevelrealwagesdecline,increasingthequantityoflabordemanded.Thereforethenominalwagerateisbidupuntiltherealwagerateisrestoredtoitsuniqueequilibriumlevel.Similarly,ifpricesfall,realwagesincrease,leadingtounemployment.Thenominalwageratefallstobringtherealwageratebacktoitsequilibriumlevel.Sothenominalwageratechangesinproportiontothepriceleveltomaintainarealwageratethatclearsthelabormarket.Atthiswagerate,thefull-employmentlevelofoutputisproduced.However,atthefull-employmentoutputleveltheunemploymentrateisnotzero.Duetofrictionsinthelabormarket,thereisalwaysapositiveunemploymentrate,asworkersswitchbetweenjobs.Thisiscalledthenaturalrateofunemployment.8.Brieflystatethereasonfortheslowadjustmentofwagestochangesinaggregatedemand.Thereasonsfortheslowadjustmentofnominalwagescanbeexplainedinseveralways.Oneexplanationisthatworkershaveimperfectinformation,thatis,theydonotimmediatelyrealizewhetherachangeintheirnominalwageistheresultofanincreaseinpricesorintherealwagetheyreceivefortheworktheyprovide.Anotherexplanationisthatcoordinationproblemsexist,thatis,differentfirmswithinaneconomyareunsureaboutthebehavioroftheircompetitorsandthustheyonlyreluctantlychangewagesorprices.Theefficiencywagetheory,ontheotherhand,arguesthatfirmspayabovemarket-clearingwagestomotivatetheirworkerstoworkharder.Firmsarealsoreluctanttochangewagesduetotheperceivedcostofdoingso.Anotherargumentisthatwagecontractstendtobelong-term,sorealwagestendtofluctuateoverthe31nlengthofthecontractandoutputadjustsonlyslowlytopricechanges.Finally,theinsider-outsidermodelarguesthatfirmsnegotiateonlywiththeiremployeesbutnottheunemployed.Sinceaturnoverofthelaborforceiscostlytofirms,theyarewillingtoofferabovemarket-clearingwagestothecurrentlyemployedratherthanhiringtheunemployedwhomaybewillingtoworkforless.Thesevariousexplanationsarenotmutuallyexclusive,andtheyallimplythattheAS-curveispositivelysloped,thatis,thatachangeinaggregatedemandwillaffectbothoutputandpricesintheshortrun.9.Trueorfalse?Why?"Thereisnofrictionalunemploymentatthenaturalrateofunemployment."False.Thenaturalrateofunemploymentistherateatwhichthelabormarketisinequilibrium.Butthereisalwayssomeunemploymentduetonewentrantsintothelaborforce,peoplebetweenjobs,andthelike.Thisrateofunemploymentisconsiderednormal,duetofrictionsinthelabormarket,andisoftencalledfrictionalunemployment.10."Ifeveryoneinthiseconomyhadrationalexpectations,thenwageswouldbeflexibleandunemploymentcouldnotoccur."Commentonthisstatement.ThenewKeynesianmodelsarguethatevenifpeoplehaverationalexpectations,sociallyundesirableoutcomesmaystilloccurduetoimperfectcompetitionandtheexistenceofwagecontracts.Pricesmaynotchangefreely,sincefirmsinimperfectlycompetitivemarketsarereluctanttochangethem,duetothemenucostsinvolved.Nominalwagesaresetbycontractsoveraperiodoftime,sotheeconomymayadjustonlyslowlytoadecreaseinaggregatedemand.Thusarateofunemploymenthigherthanthenaturalratecanexistoveranextendedperiodoftime.11.Trueorfalse?Why?"Ifnominalwagesweremoreflexible,expansionarypolicieswouldbemoreeffectiveinreducingtherateofunemployment."False.InChapter5welearnedthatintheclassicalcase(wherenominalwagesarecompletelyflexible)theAS-curveisvertical,whereasintheKeynesiancase(wherewagesdonotchange,evenifunemploymentpersists)theAS-curveishorizontal.Fromthiswecanconcludethatmoreflexiblenominalwagesimplyasteeperupward-slopingAS-curve.Anytypeofexpansionarydemand-sidepolicywillshifttheAD-curvetotherightandthiswillcausethelevelofoutputandpricestoincrease(atleastintheshort-run).Asteeperupward-slopingAS-curveresultsinalargerpriceincreaseandasmallerincreaseinoutput.Butasmallerincreaseinthelevelofoutputresultsinasmallerreductioninunemployment.Ineithercase,theeconomywillsettlebackatthefull-employmentlevelofoutputinthelongrun.Inthelongrun,therateofunemploymentalwaysgoesbacktoitsnaturallevel.3112.Explaintheshort-runandlong-runeffectsofanincreaseinthelevelofgovernmentspendingonoutput,unemployment,interestrates,prices,andrealmoneybalances.Anincreaseingovernmentspendingincreasesaggregatedemand,shiftingtheAD-curvetotheright.Becausethereisexcessdemand,thepricelevelincreases,whichreducesthelevelofrealmoneybalances.Thereforeinterestratesincrease,leadingtosomecrowdingoutofinvestment.Duetothisrealbalanceeffect,theincreaseinoutputislessthantheshiftintheAD-curve.Assuminganupward-slopingAS-curve,anewequilibriumisreachedatahigherpricelevel,ahigherlevelofoutput,alower44nunemploymentrateandahigherinterestrate.Sinceoutputisnowabovethefull-employmentlevel,wagesandpriceswillcontinuetoriseandtheupward-slopingAS-curvewillstartshiftingtotheleft.Thisprocesswillcontinueuntilanewlong-runequilibriumisreachedatthefull-employmentlevelofincomeY*,thatis,untilunemploymentisbackatitsnaturalrate.Atthispointthepricelevel,nominalwages,andinterestrateswillbehigherthanpreviouslyandrealmoneybalanceswillbelower.13.Brieflyexplainwhythereseemstobesomuchinterestinfindingwaystoshifttheupward-slopingaggregatesupplycurvetotheright.Shiftingtheupward-slopingAS-curvetotherightseemstobetheonlywaytooffsettheeffectsofanadversesupplyshockwithoutanynegativesideeffects.Anadversesupplyshock,suchasanincreaseinoilprices,causesasimultaneousincreaseinunemploymentandinflation,andpolicymakershaveonlytwooptionsfordemand-managementpolicies.Expansionaryfiscalormonetarypolicywillhelptoachievefullemploymentfasterbutwillraisethepricelevel,whilerestrictivefiscalormonetarypolicywillreduceinflationarypressurebutincreaseunemployment.Therefore,anypolicythatwouldshifttheupwardslopingAS-curvebacktotherightseemspreferable,sinceitmightbringtheeconomybacktotheoriginalequilibriumbysimultaneouslyloweringinflationandunemployment.14.UseanAD-ASframeworktoshowtheeffectofmonetaryrestrictiononthelevelofoutput,pricesandtheinterestrateinthemediumandthelongrun.Adecreaseinnominalmoneysupplywillincreaseinterestrates,leadingtoadecreaseininvestmentspending.ThiswillshifttheAD-curvetotheleft,creatinganexcesssupplyofgoodsandservices.Thereforepricelevelwilldecreaseandrealmoneybalanceswillincrease.AnewequilibriumwillbeachievedattheintersectionofthenewAD-curveandtheupward-slopingAS-curveatanoutputlevelthatisbelowthefull-employmentlevel.Inthelongrun,higherunemploymentwillcausedownwardpressureonwages.Asthecostofproductiondecreases,theupward-slopingAS-curvewillkeepshiftingtotherightuntilanewlong-runequilibriumisestablishedatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput,thatis,wherethenewAD-curveintersectsthelong-runverticalAS-curveatY*.Atthispoint,realoutput,therealinterestrate,realmoneybalances,andtherealwageratewillbebackattheiroriginallevel.Nominalmoneysupply,thepricelevelandthenominalwageratewillallhavedecreasedproportionally.Asimplifiedadjustmentcanbeshownasfollows:1-->2:Msdown==>iup==>Idown==>Ydown==>theAD-curveshiftsleft==>excesssupply==>Pdown==>realmsup==>idown==>Iup==>Yup44n(Thefirstlinedescribesapolicychange,thatis,ashiftintheAD-curve;thesecondlinedescribesthepriceadjustment,thatis,amovementalongtheAD-curve.)Short-runeffect:Ydown,iup,Pdown2-->3:SinceYdownwardspressureonnominalwages==>costofproductiondown==>theshortrunAS-curveshiftsright==>excesssupplyofgoods==>Pdown==>realmsup==>idown==>Iup==>Yup(ThisprocesscontinuesuntilY=Y*)Long-runeffect:YstaysatY*,iremainsthesame,Pdown.Note:Eventhoughonlyoneshiftoftheshort-runAS-curvetothenewlong-runequilibriumisshownhere,thisshiftisactuallyacombinationofmanyshifts.PAD1AS1AD2AS2P11P2230Y*Y2Y15.BrieflydiscusstheimportanceofOkun’slawinevaluatingthecostofunemployment.Okun’slawstatesthatareductionintheunemploymentrateof1percentwillincreasethelevelofoutputbyabout2percent.Thisrelationshipallowsustomeasurethecosttosociety(intermsoflostproduction)ofagivenrateofunemployment.16.Trueorfalse?Why?Ifmonetarypolicyaccommodatesanadversesupplyshock,itwillworsenanyinflationaryeffects."True.Anadversesupplyshockshiftstheupward-slopingAS-curvetotheleft.Thereisexcessdemandforgoodsandservicesattheoriginalpricelevelandpricesstarttorise,leadingtolowerrealmoneybalances,higherinterestrates,andloweroutput.Ifnopolicyisimplemented,thenunemploymentwillforcethenominalwagedowntorestoreequilibriumattheoriginalposition.Ifthegovernmentviewsthisadjustmentprocessastooslow,itcanrespondbyimplementingexpansionarypolicies.AccommodatingthesupplyshockinthiswayshiftstheAD-curvetotherightandanewequilibriumcanbereachedatfull-employmentbutatahigherpricelevel.Itisunlikely,though,thattheeconomywillremainthereforlongsinceworkerswillrealizethattheir44npurchasingpowerhasbeendiminishedbyhigherpricesandwilldemandawageincrease.Iftheyaresuccessful,thecostofproductionwillincreaseandtheupward-slopingAS-curvewillshifttotheleftagain.Inotherwords,wewillenterawage-pricespiral.PAD2AS2AD1AS1P3P2P10Y2Y*Y17.Assumeoilpricesdecline.WhatkindofmonetarypolicyshouldtheFedundertakeifitsgoalistostabilizethelevelofoutputwhilekeepinginflationlow?ShowwiththehelpofanAD-ASdiagramandbrieflyexplaintheadjustmentprocess.1-->2:Asoilpricesdecline,thecostofproductiondecreasesandtheupward-slopingAS-curveshiftstotheright,causingexcesssupplyofgoods.Thusthepriceleveldecreases,realmoneybalancesincrease,andtheinterestratedeclines.2-->3:Adecreaseinmoneysupplywillincreasetheinterestrate,decreaseprivatespending,andshifttheAD-curvetotheleft.Thismeansthatpriceswilldecreaseevenfurtherandthelevelofoutputwilldecline.(Weassume,forsimplicity,thatitgoesbacktothefull-employmentlevelY*,sonolong-runadjustmentisneeded.)Overall,thelevelofoutputhasremainedatitsfull-employmentlevelbutthelevelofpricesandtheinterestratehavedecreased.PAD1AS1AD2AS2P11P2230Y*Y2Y18.Commentonthefollowingstatement:"Afavorableoilshockcauseslowerinflationandlowerunemployment."Adecreaseinmaterialprices(oranyotherfavorablesupplyshock)shiftstheupward-slopingAS-curvetotheright,andpricesbegintodecrease.Thenewequilibriumisatalowerpricelevelandahigherlevelofoutput(alowerlevelofunemployment).Sinceoutputisnowabovethe44nfull-employmentlevel,therewillbeupwardpressureonnominalwagesandprices,andtheupward-slopingAS-curvewillstartshiftingbacktoitsoriginalposition(assumingthatpotentialoutputwasnotaffected).Inthelongrun,unemploymentwillbebackatitsnaturalratebutthepricelevelwillhavedecreased(andthusrealwagesincreased).19.“Fallingoilpriceswillleadtoincreasedemployment,higherwageratesandincreasedrealmoneybalances.”CommentonthisstatementwiththehelpofanAD-ASdiagramandexplaintheshort-runandlong-runadjustmentprocesses.Adeclineinmaterialpricesshiftstheupward-slopingAS-curvetotheright,leadingtoexcesssupplyattheexistingpricelevel.Anewequilibriumisreachedatahigherlevelofoutputandalowerpricelevel.Butsinceoutputisnowabovethefull-employmentlevelY*,thereisupwardpressureonwagesandpricesandtheupward-slopingAS-curvestartsshiftingbacktotheright.Anewlong-runequilibriumisreachedbackattheoriginalposition(Y*),andtheoriginalpricelevel(assumingthatthechangeinmaterialpricesdidnotaffectthefull-employmentlevelofoutput).Sincenominalwages(W)willhaverisenbutthepricelevel(P)willnothavechanged,realwages(W/P)willhaveincreased.PAD1AS1AS2P1P20Y*Y2YChapter7SolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbook:ConceptualProblems:1.Therateofunemploymentisaffectedbythefrequency,thatis,thenumberoftimesthatworkersbecomeunemployedinaperiod,andbytheduration,thatis,thelengthoftheperiodforwhichworkersareunemployed.1.a.Indepressedindustries,thedurationofunemploymentislikelytobelongbutthefrequencyislikelytobelow.Policiestohelpunemployedworkersfromtheseindustriesfindnewjobsmayincluderetrainingandeducationprogramstoenablethemtofindworkinotherindustries.1.b.Unskilledworkerstendtobemorefrequentlyunemployed,butthedurationoftheirunemploymentisusuallyfairlyshort.On-the-jobtrainingoreducationprogramsthatprovideskillstoobtainormaintainjobsareoftenthebeststrategyforhelpingtheseworkers.However,suchprogramsareoftencostlyanddifficulttoimplement.1.c.Unemploymentindepressedgeographicalareastendstobeoflongdurationandlowfrequencyandisoftenconcentratedinspecificindustries(verysimilartothesituationin1.a.).Policiestorelocateworkerstodifferentgeographicalareasmaynotbesuccessfulsinceworkersareoftenreluctantto44nmove.Thuspolicymakersgenerallypreferprogramsdesignedtoattractnewindustriestoanareaoverprogramstorelocateworkers.1.d.Teenageunemploymentisoftenofhighfrequencyandshortduration.Sinceteenagerstendtohavefewskillsandlittleornoworkexperience,programstofacilitatethetransitionintotheadultworkforceareneeded.Programsthatofferon-the-jobtrainingwillprovidethehighestlong-termbenefits.Theseprogramstendtobefairlycostly,however,whichiswhysomepoliticiansadvocateloweringtheminimumwageforteenagersinstead.2.Thenaturalunemploymentrateisdeterminedbytwofactors:thedurationandfrequencyofunemployment.Whilethedurationofunemploymentdependsprimarilyontheorganizationanddemographicmake-upofthelaborforce,theavailabilityofunemploymentbenefits,andthedesireoftheunemployedtolookforbetterjobs,thefrequencyofunemploymentdependslargelyontherateatwhichnewworkersentertheworkforceandonthevariabilityofthedemandforlaboracrossdifferentemployers.2.a.Itisunclearwhethertheeliminationofunionswouldservetoreducethenaturalrateofunemployment.Theinsider-outsidertheoryofthelabormarketsuggeststhatfirmsbargainwithunions(theinsiders)andarenotmuchconcernedwiththeunemployed(theoutsiders).Ifunionswereeliminated,firmswouldtendtohireunemployedworkersatalowerwagerate,thusreducingthenaturalunemploymentrate.Ontheotherhand,unionstendtopreservestablejobsfortheirmembers.Eliminatingthemmayleadnotonlytoareductioninbargainingpowerforlaborinwagenegotiationsbutalsotoanincreaseinthenaturalrateofunemployment.Theeliminationoflaborunionscouldalsoservetoeliminatethewagedifferentialsbetweenunionizedandnon-unionizedworkersand,intheprocess,redistributesomeincome.2.b.Increasedlaborforceparticipationofteenagerswouldatleastinitiallyincreasethenaturalrateofunemployment,sinceteenagershaveahigherfrequencyofunemploymentthanolder,moreexperiencedworkers.However,asmoreandmoreteenagersenteredthelaborforceandmoregoodandstablejobsbecameavailabletothem,thenaturalrateofunemploymentwouldstarttodeclineagain.Butwithmorepeopleinthelaborforce,thesupplyoflaborwouldbehigherandwagerateswouldbedrivendown,contributingtowagestagnation.2.c.Ifaggregatedemandfluctuatedmore,thenfirmswouldofferfewerstablejobsandthefrequencyofunemploymentwouldincrease,increasingthenaturalrate.Thiswouldnotonlyleadtoalossinoutputandanincreaseinpersonalhardship,butitwouldalsoputmorefinancialstrainontheunemploymentinsuranceprogram.2.d.Anincreaseinunemploymentbenefitswouldmakeitlessurgentfortheunemployedtofindnewjobs.Theywouldhavetheoptionoflookinglongerforjobsafterbeinglaidoffandwouldbelesslikelytoacceptundesirablejoboffers.Asthelengthoftheirunemploymentincreased,workersmightbegintolooklessdesirabletopotentialemployerswhomightbelievethattheylackedeitherthemotivationorqualificationstoworkhardforthem.Thereforethenaturalrateofunemploymentwouldincrease.2.e.Employerswhoperceivetheminimumwageratetobeabovethevalueofthemarginalproductoflowskilledworkerswillnothiresuchworkers.Theeliminationoftheminimumwageratemightinducesomefirmstohiremorelow-skilledworkers,thusdecreasingthenaturalrateofunemployment.However,thewageratethattheselowskilledworkerswereofferedmightbewellbelowtheamountthatwouldensureanadequatestandardofliving.2.f.Iffluctuationinthecompositionofaggregatedemandincreased,workerswouldhavetobeshiftedfromindustrytoindustrymoreoftenandthiswouldincreasethenaturalrateof44nunemployment.However,sinceskillsarenotalwaystransferable,resourceswouldhavetobedevotedtoretrainingprograms.3.Manyunemployedteenagersarenewentrantsintothelaborforceandtheirfrequencyofunemploymentishigherthanthatofadultworkers.Teenagers'frequencyofentryintoandexitfromthelaborforceindicatesthatfewofthemworkatjobswiththepromiseofhighjobsecurity.Theyhavelittleornotrainingandfewjobskillsandthustendtoholdunattractivejobs.Thisperpetuatestheproblemsincethejobstheycangetdonotprovidetheskillsneededtogainbetterjobsinthefuture.Whilethefrequencyofunemploymentislowerforadultsthanteenagers,thedurationisoftenhigher.Therearefewerentrantsandre-entrantsintotheworkforceamongadults,whoaremostoftenunemployedduetolayoffs.Overall,theunemploymentrateforadultsismuchlowerthantheunemploymentrateforteenagers.4.a.Employerswouldbenefitfromalowerminimumwagerate,sincetheywouldbeabletoexpandproductionbyhiringlaboratalowercost.Sincethenominalminimumwageratemightnolongerbeabovethevalueofthemarginalproductoflowskilledorinexperiencedworkers,thelaboroftheseworkerswouldbemoredesirabletoemployers.Thereforeteenagersandlowskilledjobseekerswouldalsobenefit.Theywouldgetjobsmoreeasilyandgainvaluableworkexperiencethattheyotherwisemightnothavegotten.Sincemorepeoplewouldbehiredandmoreoutputwouldbeproducedatalowerprice,thewholeeconomywouldbenefitfromalowerinflationrateandalowerunemploymentrate.4.b.Thoseworkerswhowouldhavebeenworkingatjobspayingtheexistingminimumwageratemightlosefromadecreaseintheminimumwage.Withalowerminimumwagerateimplementedonlyduringthesummermonths,employersmightlayoffcurrentworkersandreplacethemwithnewentrantsatalowercost.Thusthenumberofdisplacedworkersmightincrease.4.c.Obviously,thosewhowouldgainfromsuchapolicymeasurewouldsupportit--teenagers,lowskilledworkers,andsomefirms.5.Itispossibletodesignarestrictivefiscalandmonetarypolicymixtobringtheeconomytoalong-runequilibriumsituationatthenaturalrateofunemploymentandatazerorateofinflation.However,thiscannotbeachievedwithoutanincreaseintherateofunemploymentintheshortrun.Thereforeachoicehastobemadeamongadjustmentpathsthatdifferintheirinflation-unemploymentmix.Inconsideringadjustmentpaths,thebenefitsofpermanentlylowerinflationhavetobecomparedwiththecostsofincreasedshort-termunemployment.Thecostsofunemploymentarelossofoutputandpersonalhardship.Ifinflationcanbeanticipatedonlyimperfectly,thenaredistributionofincomeandwealthwilltakeplace.Someoutputmaybelostasresourcesaredevotedtominimizingapotentiallossinpurchasingpowerratherthantoactualproduction.However,thecostofperfectlyanticipatedinflationisminimal.Thusitprobablymakeslittledifferencewhetherwehaveazeroinflationrateoraninflationrateof3%,aslongasaspecificlong-rungoalisestablished.Apositiverateofinflationmayactuallyhelpinwageandpriceadjustments,sinceitallowsrealwagestoadjustmoreeasilytosupplyshocks.Mostpolicymakerstendtoperceivethecostofinflationaslowerthanthecostofanincreaseinunemploymentresultingfromtoughanti-inflationpolicies.However,theU.S.experienceoftheearly1980sindicatesthattoughmeasurestobringtheeconomyquicklytorecoverymaybeacceptableifinflationreachesthedouble-digitrange.OnewaytoestablishaclearinflationgoalisfortheFedtofollowamonetarygrowthrule.However,sucharulemaynotperformwellinallsituations(for44nexample,inasupplyshock).Anotheroptionistomaintaindiscretionarymonetarypolicyalongwithanindependentcentralbankthathasaclearmandatetofunctionasaninflationfighter.6.Thesacrificeratioisthepercentageofoutputlostforeachone-percentreductionintheinflationrate.Itisnon-zerointheshortandmediumruns,whenoutputisdifferentfromthefull-employmentlevel.However,inthelongrun,unemploymentalwaysreturnstoitsnaturallevelandthereforethesacrificeratioiszero.7.Okun'slawstatesthatareductionintheunemploymentrateof1percentwillincreasethelevelofoutputby2percent.Thisrelationshipallowsustomeasurethecosttosociety(intermsoflostproduction)ofagivenrateofunemployment.8.Wheninflationisperfectlyanticipated,thenitscostsconsistprimarilyofthecostsofmakingpricechanges(menucosts)andcostsrelatedtotheholdingofcurrency,whichlosespurchasingpower.Ifthereisonlylowtomoderateinflation,thesecostsareverylow.However,wheninflationratessoar,thecostscanbesubstantial.9.Thecostofimperfectlyanticipatedinflationcanbeserious.Thereisaredistributionofwealthamongindividuals.Ifactualinflationishigherthanexpected,debtorsprofitwhilecreditorsloseasrealinterestratesarelowerthanexpected.Equityholdersarealsohurt,sincetherealvalueofdividendsandcapitalgainsisreduced.Ifthereisnotaxindexation,peoplemaymoveintohighertaxbracketsandsufferfinanciallyduetobracketcreep.10.Indexationisdesignedtomakeiteasiertolivewithinflationsinceiteliminatesthecostofunanticipatedinflation.Inpractice,however,indexingonabroadbasismakesitmorecomplicatedtocalculatecontracts.Italsomakesitharderfortheeconomytoadjusttoshocksifchangesinrelativepricesareneeded.Thisisparticularlytrueforsupplyshocks.Finally,thereissomeconcernthatindexationmayweakenpoliticalmotivationtofightinflation.However,aslongasinflationislowtomoderate,thebenefitsofindexationprobablyoutweighthecosts.TechnicalProblems:1.a.Theaggregateunemploymentratecanbecalculatedbyaddingtheunemploymentratesofdifferentgroupsweightedbytheirshareofthelaborforce.Thedataintheproblemindicatethat10%ofthelaborforceareteenagers.Theadultworkforce(theother90%)isdividedinto35%femalesand65%males.Thuswegetu=(0.1)(0.19)+(0.9)[(0.35)(0.06)+(0.65)(0.07)]=0.019+(0.9)(0.021+0.0455)=0.019+0.05985=0.07885=7.9%.1.b.Ifthelaborforceparticipationrateofteenagersincreasesto15%,thentheaggregaterateofunemploymentchangesto:u1=(0.15)(0.19)+(0.85)[(0.35)(0.06)+(0.65)(0.07)]=0.0285+(0.85)(0.021+0.0455)=0.0285+0.056525=0.085025=8.5%.2.TheunemploymentfiguresforeachgroupweretakenfromtheEconomicReportofthePresident,February,1997.FiguresrelatingtotheunemploymentrateweretakenfromTableB-40andeachgroup'sshareinthecivilianlaborforcewascalculatedfromTableB-38.198619911996Males16-1944nUn.Rt./Share(19.0%)/(.030)(19.8%)/(.026)(18.1%)/(.026)Females16-19Un.Rt./Share(17.6%)/(.029)(17.5%)/(.024)(15.2%)/(.025)Males20+Un.Rt./Share(6.1%)/(.525)(6.4%)/(.520)(4.6%)/(.512)Females20+Un.Rt./Share(6.2%)/(.416)(5.7%)/(.430)(4.8%)/(.437)Iftheunemploymentrateforeachgroupinthetwootheryearswasthesameasin1991,thentheoverallunemploymentratein1986or1996wouldhavebeen:u86=(19.8%)(.030)+(6.4%)(.525)+(17.5%)(.029)+(5.7%)(.416)=0.594%+3.360%+0.508%+2.371%=6.83%u96=(19.8%)(.026)+(6.4%)(.512)+(17.5%)(.025)+(5.7%)(.437)=0.515%+3.277%+0.438%+2.491%=6.72%Theactualunemploymentratesfortheseyearswere:u86=7.0%u91=6.8%u96=5.4%Thedifferencebetweentheunemploymentratescalculatedaboveandtheunemploymentratein1986showstheeffectsofchangesinthecompositionofthelaborforceontherateofunemployment.3.ThedatamentionedhereweretakenfromtheEconomicReportofthePresident,February,1997.TableB-42ofthereportshowsunemploymentbyduration.In1991theaveragedurationwas13.7weeks,in1995itwas16.6weeks,andin1996itwas16.7weeks.(Thesenumbersreflecttheaverageamountoftimethatanunemployedworkerwasoutofworkinagivenyearandnotthedurationofacompletedspellofunemployment.)Fortheyearsinquestion,theoverallunemploymentrateswere6.8%in1991,5.6%in1995,and5.4%in1996.Thusthedurationofunemploymentmovedintheoppositedirectionfromtheoverallunemploymentrate.·CHAPTER8SolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbook:ConceptualProblems:1.Thefirstquestionyoushouldaskyourselfasapolicymakeriswhetheradisturbanceistransitoryorpersistent.Youshouldthenaskyourselfhowlongitwouldtaketoputasuggestedpolicymeasureintoeffectandhowlongitwilltakeforthepolicytohavethedesiredeffectontheeconomy.Inaddition,youneedtoknowhowreliabletheestimatesofyouradvisorsareabouttheeffectsofthepolicy.Ifadisturbanceissmallandprobablytransitory,youmaybebestadvisedtodonothing,becauseanymeasureyoutakeislikelytohaveitseffectaftertheeconomyhasrecovered.Thereforeyouractionmightonlyfurtheraggravatetheproblem.2.a.Theinsidelagisthetimeittakesafteraneconomicdisturbancehasoccurredtorecognizeandimplementapolicyactionthatwilladdressthedisturbance.2.b.Theinsidelagisdividedintothreeparts.First,thereistherecognitionlag,thatis,thetimeittakesforpolicymakerstorealizethatadisturbancehasoccurredandthatapolicyresponseiswarranted.44nSecond,thereisthedecisionlag,thatis,thetimeittakestodecideonthemostdesirablepolicyresponseafteradisturbanceisrecognized.Finally,thereistheactionlag,thatis,thetimeittakestoactuallyimplementthepolicymeasure.2.c.InsidelagsareshorterformonetarypolicythanforfiscalpolicysincetheFOMCmeetsonaregularbasistodiscussandimplementmonetarypolicy.Fiscalpolicy,ontheotherhand,hastobeinitiatedandpassedbybothhousesoftheU.S.Congressandthiscanbealengthyprocess.Theexceptionsaretheso-calledautomaticstabilizers;however,theyonlyworkwellforsmallandtransitorydisturbances2.dAutomaticstabilizershavenoinsidelag;theyareendogenousandfunctionwithoutspecificgovernmentintervention.Examplesaretheincometaxsystem,thewelfaresystem,unemploymentinsurance,andtheSocialSecuritysystem.Theyallreducetheamountbywhichoutputchangesinresponsetoaneconomicdisturbance.3.a.Theoutsidelagisthetimeittakesforapolicyaction,onceimplemented,tohaveitsfulleffectontheeconomy.3.b.Generally,theoutsidelagisadistributedlagwithasmallimmediateeffectandalargeroveralleffectoveralongertimeperiod.Theeffectisspreadovertime,sinceaggregatedemandrespondstoanypolicychangeonlyslowlyandwithalag.3.c.Outsidelagsarelongerformonetarypolicysincemonetarypolicyactionsaffectshort-terminterestratesmostdirectly,whileaggregatedemanddependsheavilyonlaggedvaluesofincome,interestrates,andothereconomicvariables.Achangeingovernmentspending,however,immediatelyaffectsaggregatedemand.4.Fiscalpolicyhassmalleroutsidelags,butsignificantinsidelags.Monetarypolicy,ontheotherhandhassmallerinsidelagsandlongeroutsidelags.Thereforelargeopenmarketoperationsshouldbeundertakentogetanimmediateeffect,buttheyshouldbepartiallyreversedovertimetoavoidalargelong-runeffect.Iftheshockissufficientlytransitoryandsmall,policymakersmaybebestadvisednottoundertakeanypolicychangeatall.5.a.Aneconometricmodelisastatisticaldescriptionofallorpartoftheeconomy.Itconsistsofasetofequationsthatarebasedonpasteconomicbehavior.5.b.Econometricmodelsaregenerallyusedtoforecastthebehavioroftheeconomyandtheeffectsofalternativepolicymeasures.5.c.Thereisconsiderableuncertaintyabouthowwelleconometricmodelsactuallyrepresenttheworkingsoftheeconomy.Thereisalsogreatuncertaintyabouttheexpectationsoffirmsandconsumersandtheirreactionstopolicychanges.Anypolicyisboundtofailiftheinformationonwhichitwasbasedispoor.6.Theanswertothisquestionisstudentspecific.Themaindifficultiesofstabilizationpolicyarisefromthreesources.First,policyalwaysworkswithlags.Second,theoutcomeofanypolicydependsonthe44nwaytheprivatesectorformsexpectationsandhowthoseexpectationsaffectthepublic'sbehavior.Third,thereisconsiderableuncertaintyaboutthestructureoftheeconomyandtheshocksthathitit.ItcanbearguedthatamonetarypolicyrulewouldgreatlyreduceuncertaintyabouttheFed'spolicyresponses.Ifthegovernmentbehavedinaconsistentway,thentheprivatesectorwouldalsobehavemoreconsistentlyandeconomicfluctuationscouldbegreatlyreduced.AmonetarygrowthrulewouldalsoreduceanypoliticalpressuretheadministrationmightexertontheFed.Itisofteninitiallyunclearwhetheradisturbanceistemporaryorpersistentandamonetarypolicyrulewouldpreventpolicymistakesincaseswherethedisturbanceis,infact,temporary.Ifactivemonetarypolicyisappliedtoatemporarydisturbance,thenthelagsinvolvedwillguaranteethattheeconomywillactuallybedestabilized.Ontheotherhand,theworkingsoftheeconomyarenotcompletelyunderstoodandeventscannotalwaysbepredicted.Thusitisdifficulttoargueforafixedpolicyrule.Unanticipatedlargedisturbanceswarrantanactivistpolicy,especiallyiftheyappeartobepersistent.Itisalsopossibletoconstructamoreactivistmonetarygrowthrule.Forexample,Equation(8)suggeststhattheannualmonetarygrowthrateshouldbeincreasedbytwopercentforeveryonepercentthatunemploymentincreasesaboveitsnaturalrate.Sucharuleisbasedonthequantitytheoryofmoneyequation(whichrelatesmoneysupplygrowthtothegrowthofnominalGDP)andonOkun'slaw(whichrelatestheunemploymentratetoeconomicgrowth).Obviously,becauseofthelonglagsformonetarypolicy,anymonetarygrowthrulewillworkmuchbetterinthelongrunthanintheshortrun.Fiscalpolicyrulesmaymakemoresensethanmonetarypolicyrules,sincefiscalpolicyhaslonginsidelagsbutshorteroutsidelags.Inaway,built-instabilizers,althoughgenerallynotconsidered"rules",alreadyprovidesomestabilitywithoutanyinsidelag.Manyoftheargumentsagainstmonetarypolicyrulesarealsovalidforfiscalpolicyrulesandmanyeconomistsopposethem.Thefrequentlyproposedconstitutionalamendmentrequiringanannuallybalancedbudgetisanexampleofafiscalpolicyrule.Therearesignificantproblemsassociatedwithsuchanamendment,sinceitwouldgreatlylimitthegovernment'sabilitytoundertakeactivefiscalstabilizationpolicy.7.Theargumentsforaconstantgrowthrateruleformoneyarebasedonthequantitytheoryofmoneyequation,thatis,MV=PY.Fromthisequationwecanderive%DP=%DM-%DY+%DV.Ifthelong-runtrendrateofrealoutput(Y)andthelong-runtrendofvelocity(V)areassumedtobefairlystable,andifwagesandpricesaresufficientlyflexible,thenaconstantmonetarygrowthrate(M)wouldinsureaconstantrateofinflation,thatis,aconstantrateofchangeinthepricelevel(P).Also,sincemonetarypolicyhaslongoutsidelags,activemonetarypolicycanactuallybemoredestabilizingthanstabilizing.Inaddition,sincewedonotknowexactlyhowtheeconomyworksormayreacttospecificpolicies,itisbesttofollowaruleratherthanundertakeactionsthathaveuncertainoutcomes.However,rulesarenotwithoutproblems,astheywouldnotallowflexibilityinrespondingtomajordisturbances.44n8.Dynamicinconsistencyoccursif,afterhavingcommittedthemselvestoaspecificpolicyactiondesignedtoachievealong-runobjective,policymakersfindthemselvesinasituationwhereitseemsadvantageoustoabandontheiroriginalpolicy,inordertoachieveashort-rungoal.Suchactionwillimpedethelong-runobjective.9.RealGDPtargetingisthebestoptioniftheprimarypolicygoalofmonetarypolicyistoachievefullemployment.IfpolicymakersforecastpotentialGDPcorrectly,thenfullemploymentcombinedwithlowinflationcanbeachieved.However,realGDPtargetingbearsthegreaterriskthatthesecondarygoalofachievingalowinflationratewillbemissed.IftherateatwhichpotentialGDPgrowsisoverestimated,thenpolicymakersmaystimulatetheeconomytoomuch.Inthiscase,theywillnotbesuccessfulinachievingpricestability.BytargetingnominalGDP,thecentralbankcreatesapolicytradeoffbetweeninflationandunemployment.IftherateatwhichpotentialGDPgrowsisoverestimatedandpolicymakersstimulatetheeconomytoomuch,wewillgetlessgrowthbutalsolessinflationthanunderrealGDPtargeting.WhichtargetingapproachshouldbechosendependsgreatlyonhowsteeporflatthePhillipscurveisperceivedtobe.TechnicalProblems:1.IfactualGDPisexpectedtobe$40billionbelowthefull-employmentlevelandthesizeofthegovernmentspendingmultiplieris2,thengovernmentspendingshouldbeincreasedby$20billionoveritscurrentlevel.Forthenextperiod,whenactualGDPisexpectedtobe$20billionbelowpotential,governmentspendingshouldbecutby$10billionfromitsnewlevel,thatis,to$10billionoveritsoriginallevel.Inperiodthree,whenactualGDPisexpectedtobeatitsfull-employmentlevel,thelevelofgovernmentspendingshouldagainbecutby$10billionfromthelastperiod'sleveltobringitbacktotheoriginallevelofPeriod0.2.a.Ifthereisaone-periodoutsidelagforgovernmentspending,thennothingcanbedonetoclosethecurrentGDP-gap.Thegovernmentshoulddecidetospend$10billionmoreforthenextperiodandreducespendingagaintoitsoriginallevelafterthat.2.b.GraphIbelowshowsthepathofGDPforProblem1withnooutsidelagandGraphIIshowsthepathofGDPforproblem2.a.withaone-periodoutsidelag.IneachofthegraphsthepathofactualGDPisshown,firstassumingthatnopolicyactiontakesplaceandthenassumingthatthepoliciesproposedinProblems1and2.a.areundertaken.GraphIGDPGDPpotentialGDPpotentialGDP0time0timeGDPwithfiscalpolicyGDPwithoutfiscalpolicy44nGraphIIGDPGDPpotentialGDPpotentialGDP0time0timeGDPwithfiscalpolicyGDPwithoutfiscalpolicy3.a.Sincethegovernmentmultiplierforthefirstperiodis1,thelevelofgovernmentspendingmustbeincreasedbyDG=$40billiontoclosetheGDP-gapof$40billion.Butsincethegovernmentmultiplierinthenextperiodfortheamountspentinthisperiodis1.5,theeffectofanincreaseingovernmentspendinginthefirstperiodby$40billionwouldbeanincreaseinGDPby$60billioninthesecondperiod.3.b.ForthesecondperiodaGDP-gapof$20billionisexpected.However,aswesawin3.a.,GDPwillincreaseby$60billioninthesecondperiodifthegovernmentincreasesspendingby$40billioninthefirstperiod.Therefore,thegovernmenthastoreducespendinginthesecondperiodby$40billionfromitsnewlevel(backtoitsoriginallevel),sincethemultiplierforaspendingchangeinthesameperiodis1.3.c.Inthisproblem,fiscalpolicyhasanoutsidelag.Thismeansthattheeffectofanincreaseingovernmentspendingisfeltbothintheperiodinwhichthespendingincreasetakesplaceand(toanevenlargerdegree)inthefollowingperiod.TheincreaseingovernmentspendingneededtoclosetheGDP-gapinthefirstperiodisguaranteedtoovershootthedesiredgoalinthenextperiod.Thusthegovernmentwillbeforcedtoreverseitsincreaseinspendingtotheoriginallevelinthesecondperiodtooffsetthedestabilizingeffect.Inacaselikethis,thegovernmenthastobemuchmoreactiveinitsfiscalpolicythaninasituationwherenodistributedlagexists.4.Ifthereisuncertaintyaboutthesizeofthemultiplier,thenfiscalpolicybecomesmuchmorecomplicated.Ifthemultiplieris1,thenanincreaseingovernmentspendingby$40billionwillclosetheGDP-gapinthefirstperiod.Ifthemultiplieris2.5,wewillovershootpotentialGDPby$60billion.Anincreaseinspendingby40/2.5=$16billionisoptimalifthemultiplieris2.5.Thusacautiousgovernmentwillprobablyincreasespendingbynomorethan$16billioninthefirstperiod,andthenreducethelevelofspendingby$8billioninthenextperiod($8billionabovetheoriginallevel).SuchapolicyactionisdesignedtoclosetheGDP-gaptosomedegreeoverthefirsttwoperiodswhileneverovershootingpotentialGDP.InPeriod3wewillagainbebackatthefull-employmentlevel.Theextenttowhichalesscautiousgovernmentmightexceedthesesuggestedspendingincreasesdependslargelyonthatgovernment'slevelofconcernaboutunemploymentversusinflation.44n5.Tofollowanestablishedruleforitspolicy,theFedneedstoknowthesourceofeachdisturbance.Ifadisturbancecomesfromthegoodssector,itisbettertohaveamonetarygrowthtarget;ifthedisturbancecomesfromthemoneysector,itisbettertohaveaninterestratetarget.44a.Assumeadisturbancecomesfromthemoneysector.Ifanincreaseinmoneydemandincreasestheinterestrate,theFedshouldtrytomaintainaconstantinterestratebyincreasingthesupplyofmoney.Thiswillre-establishtheoldequilibriumvaluesoftheinterestrateandoutputandeffectivelyoffsetthedisturbance.b.Assumeadisturbancecomesfromthegoodssector.Ifanincreaseinautonomousinvestmentincreasestheinterestrate,thenitisnotadvisabletomaintainaconstantinterestrate.Tryingtolowertheinterestrateagainbyincreasingthemoneysupplywouldaggravatethedisturbance.Ontheotherhand,maintainingaconstantmoneysupply,whilenotoffsettingthedisturbance,willatleastnotmakethingsworse.6.a.StudentswillhavetochecktheFederalReserveBulletininearly2000andcomparetheforecastsoftheFederalReserveBoardwiththeactualperformanceoftheeconomyin1999.6.b.Regardlessofhowdetaileditis,noeconometricmodelcanaccuratelyrepresenttheeconomy,sincewedonotcompletelyunderstandthewaytheeconomyworks.Therefore,wecanneverexpectperfectforecasts.Itisimpossibletoincorporatealltherelevantinformationonwhichindividualsandfirmsbasetheirexpectationsaboutthefutureandtodeterminehowtheseexpectationsaffectactionsinanygivensituation.Forecastsaregenerallybasedontheinformationavailableatthetime,whichmaybeflawedoroutdated.Inaddition,anyunexpectedchange,suchasasupplyshock,anunanticipatedinternationalchange,oranunanticipateddomesticpolicychange,canrendertheinitialpredictionswrong.CHAPTER9INCOMEANDSPENDINGSolutionstotheProblemsintheTextbook:ConceptualProblems:1.IntheKeynesianmodel,thepricelevelisassumedtobefixed,thatis,theAS-curveishorizontalandthelevelofoutputisdeterminedsolelybyaggregatedemand.Theclassicalmodel,ontheotherhand,assumesthatpricesalwaysfullyadjusttomaintainafull-employmentlevelofoutput,thatis,theAS-curveisvertical.Sincethemodelofincomedeterminationinthischapterassumesthatthepricelevelisfixed,itisaKeynesianmodel.2.Anautonomousvariable’svalueisdeterminedoutsideofagivenmodel.Inthischapterthefollowingcomponentsofaggregatedemandhavebeenspecifiedasbeingautonomous:autonomousconsumption(C*)autonomousinvestment(Io),governmentpurchases(Go),lumpsumtaxes(TAo),transferpayments(TRo),andnetexports(NXo).3.Sinceitoftentakesalongtimeforpolicymakerstoagreeonaspecificfiscalpolicymeasure,itisquitepossiblethateconomicconditionsmaydrasticallychangebeforeafiscalpolicymeasureisimplemented.Inthesecircumstancesapolicymeasurecanactuallybedestabilizing.Maybetheeconomyhasalreadybeguntomoveoutofarecessionbeforepolicymakershaveagreedtoimplementataxcut.Ifthetaxcutisenactedatatimewhentheeconomyisalreadybeginningtoexperiencestronggrowth,inflationarypressurecanbecreated.54nWhilesuchinternallagsareabsentwithautomaticstabilizers(incometaxes,unemploymentbenefits,welfare),theseautomaticstabilizersarenotsufficienttoreplaceactivefiscalpolicywhentheeconomyentersadeeprecession.4.Incometaxes,unemploymentbenefits,andthewelfaresystemareoftencalledautomaticstabilizerssincetheyautomaticallyreducetheamountbywhichoutputchangesasaresultofachangeinaggregatedemand.Thesestabilizersareapartoftheeconomicmechanismandthereforeworkwithoutanycase-by-casegovernmentintervention.Forexample,whenoutputdeclinesandunemploymentincreases,theremaybeanincreaseinthenumberofpeoplewhofallbelowthepovertyline.Ifwehadnowelfaresystemorunemploymentbenefits,thenconsumptionwoulddropsignificantly.Butsinceunemployedworkersgetunemploymentcompensationandpeoplelivinginpovertyareeligibleforwelfarepayments,consumptionwillnotdecreaseasmuch.Therefore,aggregatedemandmaynotbereducedbyasmuchasitwouldhavewithouttheseautomaticstabilizers.5.Thefull-employmentbudgetsurplusisthebudgetsurplusthatwouldexistiftheeconomywereatthefull-employmentlevelofoutput,giventhecurrentspendingortaxstructure.Sincethesizeofthefull-employmentbudgetsurplusdoesnotdependonthepositioninthebusinesscycleandonlychangeswhenthegovernmentimplementsafiscalpolicychange,thefull-employmentbudgetsurpluscanbeusedasameasureoffiscalpolicy.Othernamesforthefull-employmentbudgetsurplusarethestructuralbudgetsurplus,thecyclicallyadjustedsurplus,thehigh-employmentsurplus,andthestandardizedemploymentsurplus.Thesenamesmaybepreferable,sincetheydonotsuggestthatthereisaspecificfull-employmentlevelofoutputthatwewereunabletomaintain.TechnicalProblems:1.a.AD=C+I=100+(0.8)Y+50=150+(0.8)YTheequilibriumconditionisY=AD==>Y=150+(0.8)Y==>(0.2)Y=150==>Y=5*150=750.1.b.SinceTA=TR=0,itfollowsthatS=YD-C=Y-C.ThereforeS=Y-[100+(0.8)Y]=-100+(0.2)Y==>S=-100+(0.2)750=-100+150=50.1.c.IfthelevelofoutputisY=800,thenAD=150+(0.8)800=150+640=790.ThereforetheamountofinvoluntaryinventoryaccumulationisUI=Y-AD=800-790=10.1.d.AD'=C+I'=100+(0.8)Y+100=200+(0.8)YFromY=AD'==>Y=200+(0.8)Y==>(0.2)Y=200==>Y=5*200=1,000Note:Thisresultcanalsobeachievedbyusingthemultiplierformula:DY=(multiplier)(DSp)=(multiplier)(DI)==>DY=5*50=250,thatis,outputincreasesfromYo=750toY1=1,000.1.e.From1.a.and1.d.wecanseethatthemultiplieris5.1.f.SpY=SpAD1=200=(0.8)YADo=150+(0.8)Y20015054n07501,000Y2.a.Sincethempchasincreasedfrom0.8to0.9,thesizeofthemultiplierisnowlargerandweshouldthereforeexpectahigherequilibriumincomelevelthanin1.a.AD=C+I=100+(0.9)Y+50=150+(0.9)Y==>Y=AD==>Y=150+(0.9)Y==>(0.1)Y=150==>Y=10*150=1,500.2.b.FromDY=(multiplier)(DI)=10*50=500==>Y1=Yo+DY=1,500+500=2,000.2.c.Sincethesizeofthemultiplierhasdoubledfrom5to10,thechangeinoutput(Y)thatresultsfromachangeininvestment(I)nowhasalsodoubledfrom250to500.2.d.SpY=SpAD1=200=(0.9)YADo=150+(0.9)Y20015001,5002,000Y3.a.AD=C+I+G+NX=50+(0.8)YD+70+200=320+(0.8)[Y-(0.2)Y+100]=400+(0.8)(0.8)Y=400+(0.64)YFromY=AD==>Y=400+(0.64)Y==>(0.36)Y=400==>Y=(1/0.36)400=(2.78)400=1,111.11Thesizeofthemultiplieris(1/0.36)=2.78.3.b.BS=tY-TR-G=(0.2)(1,111.11)-100-200=222.22-300=-77.783.c.AD'=320+(0.8)[Y-(0.25)Y+100]=400+(0.8)(0.75)Y=400+(0.6)YFromY=AD'==>Y=400+(0.6)Y==>(0.4)Y=400==>Y=(2.5)400=1,000Thesizeofthemultiplierisnowreducedto2.5.3.d.BS'=(0.25)(1,000)-100-200=-50BS'-BS=-50-(-77.78)=+27.78Thesizeofthemultiplierandequilibriumoutputwillbothincreasewithanincreaseinthemarginalpropensitytoconsume.Thereforeincometaxrevenuewillalsogoupandthebudgetsurplusshouldincrease.3.e.Iftheincometaxrateist=1,thenallincomeistaxed.Thereisnoinducedspendingandequilibriumincomeonlyincreasesbythechangeinautonomousspending,thatis,thesizeofthemultiplieris1.FromY=C+I+G==>Y=Co+c(Y-1Y+TRo)+Io+Go==>Y=Co+cTRo+Io+Go=Ao4.InProblem3.d.wehadasituationwherethefollowingwasgiven:Y=1,000,t=0.25,G=200andBS=-50.Assumenowthatt=0.3andG=250==>AD'=50+(0.8)[Y-(0.3)Y+100]+70+250=370+(0.8)(0.7)Y+80=450+(0.56)Y.FromY=AD'==>Y=450+(0.56)Y==>(0.44)Y=450==>Y=(1/0.44)450=1,022.7354nBS'=(0.3)(1,022.73)-100-250=306.82-350=-43.18BS'-BS=-43.18-(-50)=+6.82Thebudgetsurplushasincreased,sincetheincreaseintaxrevenueislargerthantheincreaseingovernmentpurchases.5.a.WhileanincreaseingovernmentpurchasesbyDG=10willchangeintendedspendingbyDSp=10,adecreaseingovernmenttransfersbyDTR=-10willchangeintendedspendingbyasmalleramount,thatis,byonlyDSp=c(DTR)=c(-10).ThechangeinintendedspendingequalsDSp=(1-c)(10)andequilibriumincomeshouldthereforeincreasebyDY=(multiplier)(1-c)10.5.b.Ifc=0.8andt=0.25,thenthesizeofthemultiplierisa=1/[1-c(1-t)]=1/[1-(0.8)(1-0.25)]=1/[1-(0.6)]=1/(0.4)=2.5.ThechangeinequilibriumincomeisDY=a(DAo)=a[DG+c(DTR)]=(2.5)[10+(0.8)(-10)]=(2.5)2=55.c.DBS=t(DY)-DTR-DG=(0.25)(5)-(-10)-10=1.25AdditionalProblems:1."Anincreaseinthemarginalpropensitytosaveincreasestheimpactofoneadditionaldollarinincomeonconsumption."Commentonthisstatement.Inyouranswerdiscusstheeffectofsuchachangeinthempsonthesizeoftheexpendituremultiplier.Thefactthatthemarginalpropensitytosave(1-c)hasrisenimpliesthatthemarginalpropensitytoconsume(c)hasfallen.Thismeansthatnowoneextradollarinincomeearnedwillaffectconsumptionbylessthanbeforethereductioninthempc.Whenthempcishigh,oneextradollarinincomeraisesconsumptionbymorethanwhenthempcislow.Ifthempsislarger,thentheexpendituremultiplierwillbelarger,sincetheexpendituremultiplierisdefinedas1/(1-c).2.Usingasimplemodeloftheexpendituresectorwithoutanygovernmentinvolvement,explaintheparadoxofthriftthatassertsthatadesiretosavemaynotleadtoanincreaseinactualsaving.Theparadoxofthriftoccursbecausethedesiretoincreasesavingleadstoalowerconsumptionlevel.Butalowerlevelofspendingsendstheeconomyintoarecessionandwegetanewequilibriumatalowerlevelofoutput.Intheend,theincreaseinautonomoussavingisexactlyoffsetbythedecreaseininducedsavingduetothelowerincomelevel.Inotherwords,theeconomyisinequilibriumwhenS=Io.Sincethelevelofautonomousinvestment(Io)hasnotchanged,thelevelofsavingatthenewequilibriumincomelevelmustalsoequalIo.Thiscanalsobederivedmathematically.Sinceanincreaseindesiredsavingisequivalenttoadecreaseindesiredconsumption,thatis,DCo=-DSo,theeffectonequilibriumincomeisDY=[1/(1-c)](DCo)=[1/(1-c)](-DSo).ThereforetheoveralleffectontotalsavingisDS=s(DY)+DSo=[s/(1-c)](-DSo)+DSo=0,sinces=1-c.3."Whenaggregatedemandfallsbelowthecurrentoutputlevel,anunintendedinventoryaccumulationoccursandtheeconomyisnolongerinanequilibrium."Commentonthisstatement.Ifaggregatedemandfallsbelowtheequilibriumoutputlevel,productionexceedsdesiredspending.Whenfirmsseeanunwantedaccumulationintheirinventories,theyrespondbyreducingproduction.Thelevelofoutputfallsandeventuallyreachesalevelatwhichtotaloutput54nequalsdesiredspending.Inotherwords,theeconomyeventuallyreachesanewequilibriumatalowervalueofoutput.4.Forasimplemodeloftheexpendituresectorwithoutanygovernmentinvolvement,derivethemultiplierintermsofthemarginalpropensitytosave(s)ratherthanthemarginalpropensitytoconsume(c).Doesthisformulastillholdwhenthegovernmententersthepictureandleviesanincometax?Inthetext,theexpendituremultiplierforamodelwithoutanygovernmentinvolvementwasderivedasa=1/(1-c).Butsincethemarginalpropensitytosaveiss=1-c,themultipliernowbecomesa=1/s=1/(1-c).Inthetext,wehavealsoseenthatifthegovernmententersthepictureandleviesanincometax,thenthesimpleexpendituremultiplierchangestoa=1/[1-c(1-t)]=1/(1-c').Bysubstitutings=1-c,thisequationcanbeeasilymanipulated,togeta’=1/[1-c+ct]=1/[s+(1-s)t]=1/s'.Justass=1–c,wecansaythats'=1-c',sinces'=1-c'=1-c(1-t)=1-c+ct=s+(1-s)t.Thiscanalsobederivedinanotherway:S=YD-C=YD-(C*+cYD)=-C*+(1-c)YD=-C*+sYDIfweassumeforsimplicitythatTR=0andNX=0,thenS+TA=I+G==>-C*+sYD+TA=I*+G*==>s(Y-tY-TA*)+tY+TA*=C*+I*+G*==>[s+(1-s)t]Y=C*+I*+G*-(1-s)TA*=A*==>Y=(1/[s+(1-s)t])A*=(1/s')A*.5.Thebalancedbudgettheoremstatesthatthegovernmentcanstimulatetheeconomywithoutincreasingthebudgetdeficitifanincreaseingovernmentpurchases(G)isfinancedbyanequivalentincreaseintaxes(TA).Showthatthisistrueforasimplemodeloftheexpendituresectorwithoutanyincometaxes.Iftaxesandgovernmentpurchasesareincreasedbythesameamount,thenthechangeinthebudgetsurpluscanbecalculatedasDBS=DTAo-DG=0,sinceDTAo=DG.TheresultingchangeinnationalincomeisDY=DC+DG=c(DYD)+DG=c(DY-DTAo)+DG=c(DY)-c(DTAo)+DG=c(DY)+(1-c)(DG)sinceDTAo=DG.==>(1-c)(DY)=(1-c)(DG)==>DY=DGInthiscase,theincreaseinoutput(Y)isexactlyofthesamemagnitudeastheincreaseingovernmentpurchases(G).Thisoccurssincethedecreaseinthelevelofconsumptionduetothehigherlumpsumtaxhasexactlybeenoffsetbytheincreaseinthelevelofconsumptioncausedbytheincreaseinincome.6.Assumeamodelwithoutincometaxesandinwhichtheonlytwocomponentsofaggregatedemandareconsumptionandinvestment.Showthat,inthiscase,thetwoequilibriumconditionsY=C+IandS=Iareequivalent.54nWecanderivetheequilibriumvalueofoutputbysettingactualincomeequaltointendedspending,thatis,Y=C+I==>Y=C*+cY+I*==>(1-c)Y=C*+I*==>Y=[1/(1-c)](C*+I*)=[1/(1-c)]A*.ButsinceS=YD-C=Y-[C*+cY]=-C*+(1-c)Y,wecanderivethesameresultfromS=I*==>S=-C*+(1-c)Y=I*==>(1-c)Y=C*+I*==>Y=[1/(1-c)](C*+I*)=[1/(1-c)]A*.7.Inanefforttostimulatetheeconomyin1976,PresidentFordaskedCongressfora$20billiontaxcutincombinationwitha$20billioncutingovernmentpurchases.Doyouconsiderthisagoodpolicyproposal?Whyorwhynot?Thisisnotagoodpolicyproposal.Accordingtothebalancedbudgettheorem,equaldecreasesingovernmentpurchasesandtaxeswilldecreaseratherthanincreaseincome.Thereforetheintendedresultwouldnotbeachieved.8.Assumethefollowingmodeloftheexpendituresector:Sp=C+I+G+NXC=420+(4/5)YDYD=Y-TA+TRTA=(1/6)YTRo=180Io=160Go=100NXo=-40(a)Assumethegovernmentwouldliketoincreasetheequilibriumlevelofincome(Y)tothefull-employmentlevelY*=2,700.Byhowmuchshouldgovernmentpurchases(G)bechanged?(b)AssumewewanttoreachY*=2,700bychanginggovernmenttransferpayments(TR)instead.ByhowmuchshouldTRbechanged?(c)Assumeyouincreasebothgovernmentpurchases(G)andtaxes(TA)bythesamelumpsumofDG=DTAo=+300.Wouldthischangeinfiscalpolicybesufficienttoreachthefull-employmentlevelofoutputatY*=2,700?Whyorwhynot?(d)Brieflyexplainhowadecreaseinthemarginalpropensitytosavewouldaffectthesizeoftheexpendituremultiplier.a.Sp=C+I+G+NX=420+(4/5)[Y-(1/6)Y+100]+160+180-40=720+(4/5)(5/6)Y+80=800+(2/3)YFromY=Sp==>Y=800+(2/3)Y==>(1/3)Y=800==>Y=3*800=2,400==>theexpendituremultiplierisa=3FromDY=a(DAo)==>300=3(DAo)==>(DAo)=100ThusgovernmentpurchasesshouldbechangedbyDG=DAo=100.b.SinceDAo=100andDAo=c(DTRo)==>100=(4/5)(DTRo)==>DTRo=125.c.Thisisamodelwithincometaxes,sothebalancedbudgettheoremdoesnotapplyinitsstrictestform,whichstatesthatanincreaseingovernmentpurchasesandtaxesbyacertainamountincreasesnationalincomebythatsameamount,leavingthebudgetsurplusunchanged.Heretotaltaxrevenueactuallyincreasesbymorethan100,sincetaxesareinitiallyincreasedbyalumpsumof100,butthenincometaxesalsochangeduetothechangeinincome.ThusincomedoesnotincreasebyDY=300,aswecanseebelow.DY=a(DG)+a[(-c)(aTAo)=3*300+3*[-(4/5)300]=900-720=180ThischangeinfiscalpolicywillincreaseincomebyonlyDY=180,fromY0=2,400toY1=2,580,andwewillbeunabletoreachY*=2,700.54nd.Ifthemarginalpropensitytosavedecreases,peoplespendalargerportionoftheiradditionaldisposableincome,thatis,thempcandtheslopeofthe[C+I+G+NX]-lineincrease.Thiswillleadtoanincreaseintheexpendituremultiplierandequilibriumincome.9.AssumeamodelwithincometaxessimilartothemodelinProblem9above.Thistime,however,youhaveonlylimitedinformationaboutthemodel,thatis,youonlyknowthatthemarginalpropensitytoconsumeoutofdisposableincomeisc=0.75,andthattotalautonomousspendingisAo=900,suchthatSp=Ao+c'Y=900+c'Y.Youalsoknowthatyoucanreachthefull-employmentlevelofoutputatY*=3,150byincreasinggovernmenttransfersbyalumpsumofDTR=200.(a)Whatisyourcurrentequilibriumlevel?(b)Isitpossibletodeterminethesizeoftheexpendituremultiplierwiththeinformationyouhave?(c)Assumeyouwanttochangetheincometaxrate(t)inordertoreachthefull-employmentlevelofincomeY*=3,150.Howwouldthischangeintheincometaxrateaffectthesizeoftheexpendituremultiplier?a.SinceDA=c(DTR)=(0.75)200=150,thenew[C+I+G+NX]-lineisoftheformSp1=1,050+c1Y.Foreachmodeloftheexpendituresectorwecanderivetheequilibriumlevelofincomebyusingthefollowingequation:Y*=aAo=1/(1-c’)==>3,150=a1,050==>theexpendituremultiplierisa=3.IfwenowchangeautonomousspendingbyDA=150,thenincomewillhavetochangebyDY=a(DA)==>DY=3*150=450.ThereforetheoldequilibriumlevelofincomemusthavebeenY=3,150-450=2,700.b.Fromourworkabovewecanseethatthesizeofthemultiplierisa=3.c.Thenew[C+I+G+NX]-lineisoftheformSp2=900+c2Y.Thisnewintendedspendinglineintersectsthe45-degreelineatY=3,150.Thustheslopeofthenewintendedspendinglinecanbederivedasc2=(3,150-900)/(3,150)=5/7.FromY=Sp2==>Y=900+(5/7)Y==>(2/7)Y=900==>Y=(7/2)900=(3.5)900=3,150.Thenewvalueofthemultiplieris3.5SpY=SpSp2=900+(5/7)YSp1=900=(2/3)Y3,150rise900run54n02,7003,150Y10.Assumeyouhavethefollowingmodeloftheexpendituresector:Sp=C+I+G+NXC=400+(0.8)YDIo=200Go=300+(0.1)(Y*-Y)YD=Y-TA+TRNXo=-40TA=(0.25)YTRo=50(a)WhatisthesizeoftheoutputgapifpotentialoutputisatY*=3,000?(b)Byhowmuchwouldinvestment(I)havetochangetoreachequilibriumatY*=3,000,andhowdoesthischangeaffectthebudgetsurplus?(c)Fromthemodelaboveyoucanseethatgovernmentpurchases(G)arecounter-cyclical,thatistheyareincreasedasnationalincomedecreases.IfyoucomparethisspecificationofGwithaconstantlevelofG,howisthevalueoftheexpendituremultiplieraffected?(d)AssumetheequationfornetexportsischangessuchthatNXo=-40isnowNX1=-40-mY,with0Y=1,200+(0.5)Y==>(0.5)Y=1,200==>Y=2*1,200=2,400TheoutputgapisY*-Y=3,000-2,400=600.b.FromDY=(mult.)(DA)==>600=2(DI)==>DI=300BuS=TA-TR-G=(0.25)(2,400)-50-[300+(0.1)(600)]=600-50-300-60=190BuS*=(0.25)(3,000)-50-300=400,sothebudgetsurplusincreasesbyDBuS=210.c.Ifgovernmentpurchasesareusedasastabilizationtool,thesizeofthemultipliershouldbelowerthanifthelevelofgovernmentspendingisfixed.Inthemodeloftheexpendituresectorabove,theslopeofthe[C+I+G+NX]-lineisc'=0.5comparedtoc"=0.6,whengovernmentpurchasesweredefinedasG=300.d.Withthischange,netexportsdecreaseasnationalincomeincreases.Thisadditionalleakageimpliesthatthesizeofthemultiplierwilldecrease.Inthemodelabove,theslopeofthe[C+I+G+NX]-linedecreasesfromc'=(0.5)toc"=(0.5)-m.Thereforetheexpendituremultiplierwilldecreasefrom1/[1-(0.5)]to1/[1-(0.5)+m].11.Assumeyouhavethefollowingmodeloftheexpendituresector:Sp=C+I+G+NXC=Co+cYDYD=Y-TA+TRTA=TAoTR=TRoI=IoG=GoNX=NXo(a)Ifadecreaseinincome(Y)by800leadstoadecreaseinsavings(S)by160,whatisthesizeoftheexpendituremultiplier?(b)Ifadecreaseintaxes(TA)by400leadstoanincreaseinincome(Y)by1,200,howlargeisthemarginalpropensitytosave?(c)Ifanincreaseinimportsby200(DNX=-200)leadstoadecreaseinconsumption(C)by800,whatisthesizeoftheexpendituremultiplier?Recallthattheexpendituremultiplierforsuchasimplemodelcanbecalculatedas:a=1/(1-c)a.(DS)/(DY)=1-c=(-160)/(-800)=.2==>1/(1-c)=1/(.2)=5==>themultiplierisa=5.b.From(DY)=a[-c(DTAo)]==>(DY)/(DTAo)=(-c)a=(-c)/(1-c)==>54n(1,200)/(-400)=-3=(-c)/(1-c)==>-3(1-c)=-c==>c=3/4==>mps=1-c=1/4=0.25.c.DY=DC+DNX=-800+(-200)=-1,000==>c=(DC)/(DY)=(-800)/(-1,000)=.8==>multiplier=a=1/(1-c)=1/(.2)=512.Explainwhyincometaxation,theSocialSecuritysystem,andunemploymentinsuranceareconsideredautomaticstabilizers.Incometaxes,unemploymentbenefits,andtheSocialSecuritysystemareoftencalledautomaticstabilizersbecausetheyreducetheamountbywhichoutputchangesasaresultofachangeinaggregatedemand.Thesestabilizersareapartofthestructureoftheeconomyandthereforeworkwithoutanyactualgovernmentintervention.Forexample,whenoutputdeclinesandunemploymentincreases.Ifwehadnounemploymentinsurance,peopleoutofworkwouldnotreceiveanydisposableincomeandthenconsumptionwoulddropsignificantly.Butsinceunemployedworkersgetunemploymentcompensation,consumptionwillnotdecreaseasmuch.Therefore,aggregatedemandmaynotbereducedbyasmuchasitwouldhavewithouttheseautomaticstabilizers.13.Assumeasimplemodeloftheexpendituresectorwithapositiveincometaxrate(t).Showmathematicallyhowanincreaseinlumpsumtaxes(TAo)wouldaffectthebudgetsurplus.FromBS=TA-G-TR=tY+TAo-G–TR==>DBS=t(DY)+DTAo=t(mult.)(-c)(DTAo)+DTAo=t[1/(1-c+ct)](-c)(DTAo)+DTAo=([-(ct)+1-c+(ct)]/[1-c+(ct)])(DTAo)=(1-c)/[1-c+(ct)])(DTAo)>0,sincec<1Inotherwords,alumpsumtaxincreasewouldincreasethebudgetsurplus.14.Trueorfalse?Why?"Ataxcutwillincreasenationalincomeandwillthereforealwaysincreasethebudgetsurplus."False.Althoughataxcutraisesnationalincome,notalloftheincreaseinincomeisspent,norisitcompletelytaxedaway.Incometaxrevenuesfallandthebudgetdeficitrises.Assumethefollowingmodeloftheexpendituresector:Sp=C+I+G+NXI=IoC=Co+cYDG=GoYD=YTA+TRNX=NXoTA=TAo+tYBS=TA-G-TRTR=TRoFromY=Sp==>Y=Co+c(Y-TAo-tY+TRo)+Io+Go+NXo==>Y=Co-cTAo+cTRo+Io+Go+NXo+c(1-t)Y=Ao+c'Y==>Y=[1/(1-c')]Aowithc'=c(1-t)ThusDY=[1/(1-c')][(-c)(DTAo)]andDBS=t(DY)+(DTAo)={[t(-c)]/(1-c')+1}(DTAo)==>={[-(ct)+1-c+(ct)]/[1-c+(ct)]}(DTAo)={(1-c)/[1-c+(ct)]}(DTAo)>0ifDTA>0.Therefore,iftaxesfall,thatis,ifDTA<0,thebudgetsurplusdecreases.15.Assumeasimplemodeloftheexpendituresectorwithapositiveincometaxrate(t).Showmathematicallyhowadecreaseinautonomousinvestment(Io)wouldaffectthebudgetsurplus.Adecreaseinautonomousinvestment(Io)willhaveamultipliereffectandwillthereforedecreasenationalincomeandtaxrevenue.Thebudgetsurpluswilldecreaseasshownbelow:DBS=t(DY)=ta(DIo)<054n16."Anincreaseingovernmentpurchaseswillalwayspayforitself,asitraisesnationalincomeandhencethegovernment'staxrevenues."Commentonthisstatement.Anincreaseingovernmentpurchaseswillincreasethebudgetdeficit.Ifweassumeamodeloftheexpendituresectorwithincometaxes,thenthemultiplierequals[1/(1-c')]withc'=c(1-t).ThechangeinthebudgetsurplusthatarisesfromachangeingovernmentpurchasescanbecalculatedasDBS=t(DY)-DG=t[1/(1-c')](DG)-DG={[t-1+c-(ct)]/[1-c+(ct)]}(DG)=-{[(1-c)(1-t)]/(1-c+(ct)]}(DG)<0,sineDG>0.Therefore,ifgovernmentpurchasesareincreased,thebudgetsurpluswilldecrease.17.Isthesizeoftheactualbudgetsurplusalwaysagoodmeasurefordeterminingfiscalpolicy?Whataboutthesizeofthefull-employmentbudgetsurplus?Theactualbudgetsurplushasacyclicalandastructuralcomponent.Thecyclicalcomponentofthebudgetsurpluschangeswithchangesinthelevelofincomewhetherornotanyfiscalpolicymeasurehasbeenimplemented.Thisimpliesthattheactualbudgetsurplusalsochangeswithchangesinincomeandisthereforenotaverygoodmeasureforassessingfiscalpolicy.Thestructural(full-employment)budgetsurplusiscalculatedundertheassumptionthattheeconomyisatfull-employment.Itthereforechangesonlywithachangeinfiscalpolicyandisamuchbettermeasureforfiscalpolicythantheactualbudgetsurplus.Oneshouldkeepinmind,however,thatthebalancedbudgettheoremimpliesthatthegovernmentcanstimulatenationalincomebyanequivalentandsimultaneousincreaseintaxesandgovernmentpurchases,therebyaffectingtheactualorthefull-employmentbudgetsurplus.18.Assumeamodeloftheexpendituresectorwithincometaxes,inwhichpeoplewhopaytaxes,haveahighermarginalpropensitytoconsumethanpeoplewhoreceivegovernmenttransfers,andtheconsumptionfunctionisofthefollowingform:C=Co+c(Y-TA)+dTR,withcDY=[(-c)/(1-c')(DTAo)+[1/(1-c')](DG)=[(1-c)/(1-c')](-100)<0c'=c(1-t)Nationalincomewoulddecrease.DBS=t(DY)+DTAo-DG=t(DY)<0Thebudgetsurpluswoulddecreasebythelossinincometaxrevenue.b.AssumethatDTAo=DTRo=-100==>DY=[(-c)/(1-c')](DTAo)+[d/(1-c')](DTRo)=[(d-c)/(1-c')](-100)<0c'=c(1-t)Nationalincomewouldincrease.DBS=t(DY)+DTAo-DTRo=t(DY)<0Thebudgetsurpluswoulddecrease.19.Trueorfalse?Why?"Thehigherthemarginalpropensitytoimport,thelowerthesizeofthemultiplier."True.Importsrepresentaleakageoutoftheincomeflow.Anincreaseinautonomousspendingwillraiseincomeandwewillseetheusualmultipliereffect.However,ifimportsarepositivelyrelatedtoincome,thiseffectisreducedsincehigherimportsreducethelevelofdomesticdemand.ClosedEconomyModelOpenEconomyModelSp=C+I+GSp=C+I+G+NXC=Co+cYC=Co+cY54nG=GoG=GoI=IoI=IoNX=NXomYwithm>0FromY=Sp==>Y=(Co+Io+Go)+cYY=(Co+Io+Go+NXo)+(c-m)YY=Ao+cYY=Ao+(c-m)YY=[1/(1-c)]AoY=[1/(1-c+m)]AoThereforethemultiplierisdefinedas[1/(1c)][1/(1c+m)]Clearlytheopeneconomymultiplierfallsshortoftheclosedeconomymultiplier.Thisisbecauseleakagesreducedemand.Ifincometaxeswereincludedinthesemodels,theytoowouldreducethemultipliers,asincometaxesrepresentanotherleakagefromtheincomeflow.54
查看更多

相关文章

您可能关注的文档