- 2022-08-17 发布 |
- 37.5 KB |
- 10页
申明敬告： 本站不保证该用户上传的文档完整性，不预览、不比对内容而直接下载产生的反悔问题本站不予受理。
文档介绍
如何研究中古哲学
LecturetobedeliveredonMay16,1944attheFourthInstituteofBiblicalandPost-BiblicalStudies.HowToStudyMedievalPhilosophyLEOSTRAUSS“HowToStudyMedievalPhilosophy”wasavailabletotheeditorsinProfessorStrauss’soriginaltypescript,withadditions,correctionsandalterationsaddedinpencilinhisownhand.WearegratefultoHeinrichandWiebkeMeierfortheirmostgeneroushelpindecipheringProfessorStrauss’shandwritingandtoHillelFradkinforhelpwithregardtoHebrewandArabicwords.Afewminorchangesbytheeditorsinspellingandpunctuationhavenotbeennoted.Weraisethequestionofhowtostudymedievalphilosophy.Wecannotdiscussthatquestionwithoutsayingsomethingabouthowtostudyearlierphilosophyingeneralandindeedabouthowtostudyintellectual’history*ingeneral.Inasense,theanswertoourquestionisself-evident.Everyoneadmitsthat,ifwehavetostudymedievalphilosophyatall,wehavetostudyitasexactlyandasintelligentlyaspossible.Asexactlyaspossible:wearenotpermittedtoconsideranydetailhowevertrifling,unworthyofourmostcarefulobservation.Asintelligentlyaspossible:inourexactstudyofalldetails,wemustneverlosesightofthewhole;wemustnever,foramoment,overlookthewoodforthetrees.Butthesearetrivialities,althoughwehavetoaddthattheyaretrivialitiesonlyifstatedingeneralterms,andthattheyceasetobetrivialitiesifonepaysattentiontothemwhileengagedinactualwork:thetemptationstoloseoneselfincuriousandunexploreddetailsontheonehand,andtobegenerousasre-gardsminutiaeontheother,arealwayswithus.Wetouchuponamorecontroversialissuewhenwesaythatourunderstand-ingofmedievalphilosophymustbehistoricalunderstanding.Frequentlypeo-plerejectanaccountofthepast,notsimplyasunexactorunintelligent,butasunhistorical.Whatdo’theymeanbyit?Whatoughttheytomeanbyit?’AccordingtoasayingofKant,itispossibletounderstandaphilosopherbetterthanheunderstoodhimself.Now,suchunderstandingmayhavethegreatestmerits;butitisclearlynothistoricalunderstanding.Ifitgoessofarastoclaimtobe(hetrueunderstanding,itispositivelyunhistorical.[ThemostoutstandingexampleofsuchunhistoricalinterpretationwhichwehaveinthefieldofthestudyofJewishmedievalphilosophy,isHermannCohen’sessayonMaimonides’ethics.CohenconstantlyrefersstatementsofMaimonides,notto\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n查看更多